Daniel PS Goh
Reflections on my mood swings on the President's address in May:
1. Lots of expectations for a political reform big bang so that governance would keep up with society, and then a great deflating sound as the President offered lots of motherhood semantics echoing previous speeches, not his fault because this is tradition?
2. Re-calibrated expectations for the details from the Ministers and the only wow was the nationalisation of the public bus system, which is to be called "government contracting" to avoid semantic confusion with the nationalisation called for by WP and others
3. Dragging my hopes into the debate this week, met in the first day by WP's Faisal offering a "social protection" framework to organise the kueh lapis charity bake, and WP's Low on his take on a public-centred constructive politics
4. A tad disappointed that the response to Low turned into partisan finger-pointing to paint WP as semantically compromised "flip flopper", with unsubstantiated great claims that the record clearly show this (because it is so clear, there is no need to show where in the record?)
5. Mere semantics turned into a semantic shoot-out with the PM accusing WP of being semantic weasels playing with words, though I learned that a "flip flop" becomes a "shift" when one admits to a "flip flop" (and thus we could logically conclude there is no such thing as a "flip flop" except rhetorically in a semantic shoot-out)
6. Because all eyes were now on the semantic shoot-out, new meaningful points were missed: the flip-flop-shift on retirement adequacy and CPF, WP Png's call for greater flexibility for older Singaporeans to access CPF savings, and PAP Baey's point on keeping policies simple, semantically and syntactically
All in all, a disappointment, a debate dismay.
But at least it was no debacle. At least partisan politics no longer descends into legal and character shoot-outs outside of Parliament, but involve rather benign semantic shoot-outs in Parliament that has revived interest in Parliament.
Okay, now it is the turn for going two steps forward.