NDP contrarian view

[Leongsam]

You are so outdated with your military doctrine

Walking softly and carrying a big stick never goes out of date.

 

[Leongsam]

Darling. What kind of natural resources can they harvest with an invasion? @ginfreely on a pedestal?

Invasions are not always about natural resources. They are often about neutralising influence.

 

[Hypocrite-The]

When there is pandemic, there is panic buying. For sure they can sell everything to their own market.

So why aren't they eliminating food imports to singkieland?

 

[nayr69sg]

So why aren't they eliminating food imports to singkieland?

Because Malaysia very nice. Take care of Singapore.

 

[ckmpd]

Our food sources are from all over the world. The only way they can deny us food is to block shipping lanes, which will lead to open warfare.

you want to feed 6m people importing fo

Walking softly and carrying a big stick never goes out of date.

You quoted Roosevelt wrongly...It is "speak softly and carrying a big stick"..

Roosevelt's saying is not relevant in a globalised world. It shd be "speak softly, carry a big stick and remain self sufficient in basic needs.

PAP's doctrine is "talk loudly, carry a big stick and depend on the world to provide our food. I can see the flaw in pap's military doctrine

 

[ckmpd]

So why aren't they eliminating food imports to singkieland?

Malaysia is slowly letting Singapore get complacent but it knows it holds SG's balls. Do you not see how vulnerable Singapore is?

A country which is unable to be self sufficient in water and food is not truly independent

 

[ckmpd]

Because Malaysia very nice. Take care of Singapore.

That is not true. Malaysia needs SG for now too. Malaysia does not supply food to SG because it is nice to Singapore. Let us be clear abt that

 

[ckmpd]

We have eggs coming as far as poland and fish from alaska. If our neighbours want to choke off our trade routes, it's open war.

dont sell you eggs is open war? Protecting is own water way is open war? defending malacca straits is open war? what kind of logic is that?

 

[nayr69sg]

you want to feed 6m people importing fo

You quoted Roosevelt wrongly...It is "speak softly and carrying a big stick"..

Roosevelt's saying is not relevant in a globalised world. It shd be "speak softly, carry a big stick and remain self sufficient in basic needs.

PAP's doctrine is "talk loudly, carry a big stick and depend on the world to provide our food. I can see the flaw in pap's military doctrine

Singapore cannot remain self sufficient in basic needs. Not possible.

 

[nayr69sg]

Malaysia is slowly letting Singapore get complacent but it knows it holds SG's balls. Do you not see how vulnerable Singapore is?

A country which is unable to be self sufficient in water and food is not truly independent

Correct. Singapore is just a city state that is totally dependent on the generosity of other nations sharing their food in trade.

Extremely vulnerable.

Hence the SAF is a tool to threaten others if they refuse to sell food water and fuel.

 

[nayr69sg]

That is not true. Malaysia needs SG for now too. Malaysia does not supply food to SG because it is nice to Singapore. Let us be clear abt that

Malaysia is being nice to SG. If they wanted to Malaysia will overrun sg anytime. As you have always maintained SAF is run by ball less men.

 

[ckmpd]

Malaysia is being nice to SG. If they wanted to Malaysia will overrun sg anytime. As you have always maintained SAF is run by ball less men.

Agree. Malaysia can overrun SG, But it will be at great costs to Malaysia. Singaporeans who think F15s and submarines can win the war is delusional. If I were Malaysia, just let SG come in and occupy Johore. See how long SAF can hold and last in Malaysia. That is the real hard truth

 

[ckmpd]

Correct. Singapore is just a city state that is totally dependent on the generosity of other nations sharing their food in trade.

Extremely vulnerable.

Hence the SAF is a tool to threaten others if they refuse to sell food water and fuel.

SAF is a tool to allow pap to cut off SG guys' balls and create jobs and allow its cronies to make money

 

[ckmpd]

Singapore cannot remain self sufficient in basic needs. Not possible.

Agree. SG needs a hinterland. If cant sustain basic needs, cant call ourselves as independent. We survive because others are generous towards us. SG cant compel any country to sell it food. That is the truth

 

[Hypocrite-The]

dont sell you eggs is open war? Protecting is own water way is open war? defending malacca straits is open war? what kind of logic is that?

Straits of malacca is an international open water way.closing it off is tantamount to war

 

[bobby]

Our Macik only works 1 day in the year...9 Aug.

So can take back her salary for 2020 ???

 

[ckmpd]

Straits of malacca is an international open water way.closing it off is tantamount to war

If malaysia exercises its international right to impose its economic zone and chooses to selectively harass SG bound ships, but allow others to sail through, what can SG do to? There are many things, Malaysia can do to irritate and harass SG.

What happened to the Seletar airport ILS? Stuck?

What happened to malaysian boats sailing into SG declared waters? SG stuck? Despite NEH's boast, SG cant do anything and have silently kept the news from Singaporeans.

If malaysia wants to harass, it will definitely affect the flow of food and goods into SG.

 

[ckmpd]

Our Macik only works 1 day in the year...9 Aug.

So can take back her salary for 2020 ???

Halimah is a waste of public funds

 

[nayr69sg]

If malaysia exercises its international right to impose its economic zone and chooses to selectively harass SG bound ships, but allow others to sail through, what can SG do to? There are many things, Malaysia can do to irritate and harass SG.

What happened to the Seletar airport ILS? Stuck?

What happened to malaysian boats sailing into SG declared waters? SG stuck? Despite NEH's boast, SG cant do anything and have silently kept the news from Singaporeans.

If malaysia wants to harass, it will definitely affect the flow of food and goods into SG.

Exactly. SG is actually very very vulnerable and useless. If not for money SG has nothing.

That is why you must really give it to all the patriotic sinkies still loving this useless island and wanting to stay and risk starvation and death.

 

[ckmpd]

If malaysia exercises its international right to impose its economic zone and chooses to selectively harass SG bound ships, but allow others to sail through, what can SG do to? There are many things, Malaysia can do to irritate and harass SG.

What happened to the Seletar airport ILS? Stuck?

What happened to malaysian boats sailing into SG declared waters? SG stuck? Despite NEH's boast, SG cant do anything and have silently kept the news from Singaporeans.

If malaysia wants to harass, it will definitely affect the flow of food and goods into SG.

Many dim wit singaporeans just swallow pap's propaganda. My advice is grow some balls and put on your thinking cap. Dont dumbly quote F15s, submarines, strong saf, etc. If you go into a country and have no forces to hold ground and resupply, you are dead when the enemy cuts you off