Imho, Liu has a very good case against LBW. Firstly, the words she uttered against him were clearly disparaging and hurtful as a professional TT coach; secondly she made these comments in public and finally one may ask; is she telling the truth,in which case she has a good defence but if not was it fair comment? Can she substantiate her allegations against Liu? Bearing in mind that he was engaged by STTA whose one lofty ambition was to bring home an Olympic medal, he did deliver the goods. Other allegations such as his bad attitude, lack of professionalism etc are subjective and she needs to show proof? Can she do it? She is being very vindictive that's all. Not nominating him for coach of the year is already sufficient punishment! She obviously tried to rub it in. Serve her right.