Yes you are right.
No offence to anyones religious sensitivities/practices.
I feel that the ashes should be dispersed at sea (atleast in my case).
Atleast then our kids wont feel the pressure of having to visit our niches.
I think whatever our kids wanna do for us they must do it when we are alive... Not when we are dead and gone...!!
[QUOTE Bigfatfish when i die i want everything to disappear from the face of this earth./// Analytical Professor;795170] Scattering ashes at sea is good right? At least then no 30 years problem and secondly our kids will not be forced to come and visit the niches.
With respect to everyone else's view, religious or emotional, I have never understood this need to preserve ashes. Yes, respect for the body of any human being and certainly not to allow disrespect to the corpse in any way, specially mutilation. But I was a witness to my mother's annual visit to my father's grave and the deep sorrow each visit would produce for days.
I don't think any religion teaches that any part of the spirit or soul still resides in the remains - whether we bury, cremate, cover with goldleaf or allow birds to pick the corpse clean.
Nor do any of the religions teach that prayers said at the graveside/halls of niches/family altar penetrates and benefits
the actual ashes or bones of the dear one who has moved on. Surely it is for
the soul or spirit of the loved one.
I was amazed to hear, some years ago, all about the different prices for the niches: the higher up ones give
a better view, light and airiness and the lower and cheaper ones are too close to people's feet etc etc It dawned on me then how much money can be made from this from people who are grieving (and grieving in advance!), and how much better use that money could be put
right now to feeding the poor, clothing and housing the desperate, to scientific research into horrible diseases, educating children and ignorant adults [who want education but could never afford it], cleaning up the planet, preserving the rainforest and the seas, helping in so many ways living people in need. And if not, to having a good time with that money while there is still life in you. At least donate the money to groups of religious, nuns or monks, who will pray for the departed soul - it will keep the temple or church in repair and provide them with sustenance while they are doing the praying for you, you lazy sod.
My same mother, when asked about the distribution of her personal effects, said this most liberating thing: Oh do what you like dear, I'll be dead and gone!
I mean no disrespect to anyone else's views on how best to commemorate the loss of a dearly loved one.[/QUOTE]