The current situation is much more complex. The key points to note are :
1. What are left in the CPF of many people are really "not enough" for retirement because house price, medical cost ..... all went up, whiled wage stagnated.
2. The CPF monies are already invested. With the baby boomer hitting 55 all at around the same time, liquidation of these investments to pay back this large group is not viable.
3. Those who do not have enough CPF for retirement are usually the same group who are weak in managing their finances (having over stretched in property). So they are more vulnerable to spending all their money and end up becoming a huge burden.
4. The size of the workforce is falling, which means decreasing in-flow of cheap CPF funds.
Faced with the above issues, the wise scholars have come up with these :
a. Increasing minimum sum to prevent sudden out-flow of CPF fund due to baby boomers hitting 55. It will also serve to prevent those poor in managing their money from spending them in one go.
b. Increasing house price so that CPF money is subtly being transferred from the individuals to the govt permanently, so that there will be less or nothing left to withdraw at 55 - resolving the headache once and for all.
c. Created CPF Life to make those with more CPF money to share the burden of taking care of those who have not enough.
d. Created Medishield Life to make those who stays healthy to sudsidize for those who can't afford through increased premium.
e. Increasing FT to sustain the in-flow of CPF fund and to maintain economy and property price.
These are great ideas on paper. However, the social price have not been addressed :
1. Increase in FT led to depressed wages and job lost, leading to less CPF for locals.
2. Increasing minimum sum dashed the people's dream of getting a sum to splurge at 55.
3. Increasing house price make youngsters feel like fools, working for the entire life just to pay for a flat with little left at the end.
These side effects led people to start questioning the interest rate paid by CPF and other issues, all thrown in and mixed like rojak. It is really a problem of one clever move too many. Once pushed past the limit, all related questions will surface and credibility is lost. This is fatal because nobody is going to believe any more, even if the intention is good.