Singapore’s star banker creates a succession dilemma for DBS
Bloomberg
Mon, 3 July 2023 at 11:04 am SGT·9-min read
In this article:
- Piyush Gupta
Singaporean Banker
Piyush Gupta, chief executive officer of DBS Group Holdings Ltd., during a news conference in Singapore, on Monday, Feb. 13, 2023. (Suhaimi Abdullah/Bloomberg)
By Chanyaporn Chanjaroen
(Bloomberg) — For more than 13 years, Piyush Gupta has led one of Singapore’s most iconic institutions, the bank that helped turn the Southeast Asian city-state into one of the richest countries in the world.
In his time as chief executive officer at DBS Group Holdings Ltd., Gupta has built the lender into Singapore’s largest listed company, moved early into wealth management and other key business areas and delivered equity returns that outstrip global peers.
Now, that very success is creating an elephant in the room.
At conferences, shareholder meetings and townhalls, people who watch the bank closely are quietly asking the same questions: Who’s going to replace the 63-year-old executive when his long stint ends? When will that happen? And will they be able to emulate his run? Even after a recent series of online banking disruptions angered retail customers, industry observers say Gupta’s record is intact — and the bank’s biggest challenge is finding his successor.
“These issues should have no bearing on Piyush’s legacy, nor are they unique to DBS,” said Vikram Pandit, who was CEO of Citigroup Inc. from 2007 to 2012 and overlapped with Gupta at the US bank. “It’s always hard to imagine how a new leader can step into the shoes of a highly successful predecessor,” he said. “But great CEOs and institutions have well-defined succession plans.”
It’s a textbook example of the phenomenon known as key-person risk, a reminder that companies must be ready for when a longtime chief departs. And there’s much more at stake than just the share price: So integral is DBS to Singapore that how it solves the puzzle matters to the city-state as a whole.
Gupta is in many ways the Jamie Dimon of Singapore, the highest-profile banker leading the country’s largest lender and surrounded by succession speculation. And while DBS says Gupta isn’t going anywhere, the bank has been making moves that some see as precursors to eventually passing the baton.
In February, DBS unveiled a major leadership reorganization, ensuring the four people earmarked as internal candidates for the top post hold some of the most important jobs.
Shee Tse Koon, the then Singapore country head, took over consumer banking and wealth management, the No. 2 revenue-generator. Han Kwee Juan, who Gupta hired from Citi in 2019, moved into Shee’s old role. Lim Him Chuan, 54, the longest-serving of the four, relocated to Singapore to replace Han as group head of strategy and planning. The fourth, and the only woman, Tan Su Shan, kept her position running institutional banking, DBS’s crown jewel.
Tan Su Shan. (Ore Huiying/Bloomberg)
Tan, 55, is credited with expanding the consumer and wealth business, which accounted for about a third of pretax profit by the time she moved to her current job in 2019. Shee, 53, spent more than two decades at Standard Chartered Plc in London, Dubai and as CEO for Indonesia. Han, also 55, worked at Citi for 27 years, running businesses including treasury and markets, corporate and investment banking and cash management. And Lim previously ran the Taiwan unit for almost five years, while also holding roles in areas including institutional banking.
People familiar with the matter say there’s no clear favorite to inherit Gupta’s 45th-floor office at the Marina Bay Financial Centre, the bank’s headquarters overlooking Singapore’s waterfront. Hiring an outsider also can’t be ruled out, the people said, asking not to be identified discussing private information.
“A departure without a clear succession plan and new leader seen to be able to execute strongly may negatively impact the stock,” said Kevin Kwek, a former analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein who covered banks including DBS for more than a decade. Still, he says any selloff would be temporary because the “bench is prepared well” and Gupta “has already gotten the hardest part done.”
DBS has been preparing for Gupta’s succession for about 10 years, according to a person familiar with the matter. The bank is looking for someone who can do things differently going into the next decade as technologies such as artificial intelligence increase in importance, the person said, asking not to be identified discussing confidential information.
“DBS has deep bench strength and is committed to grooming talent from within,” said Karen Ngui, a spokeswoman for the bank. The February reshuffle “testifies to that,” she said. “At present, Piyush has no plans to retire, and any speculation on potential CEO candidates is thus premature.”
The DBS Group headquarters at the Marina Bay Financial Centre in Singapore. (Munshi Ahmed/Bloomberg)
DBS was founded in 1968, three years after Singapore was expelled from Malaysia and became an independent country. It was called Development Bank of Singapore, a nod to the role it was expected to play in financing the nation’s emerging industries. DBS went on to lead the initial public offerings of some of Singapore Inc.’s iconic companies, including Singapore Airlines Ltd. in 1985 and Singapore Telecommunications Ltd. in 1993.
Today, it’s Southeast Asia’s largest bank by assets, with about 36,000 employees in 19 markets. Its city-state home is also thriving. Singapore’s gross domestic product per capita, based on purchasing power parity, ranks third in the world at US$133,890, according to the International Monetary Fund.
When Gupta joined as CEO in November 2009, things weren’t going so well for DBS. His predecessor, Richard Stanley, had died of leukemia 11 months into the job. Under Jackson Tai, the chief before Stanley, the bank had suffered losses on collateralized debt obligations, along with its Singapore peers. Efforts to expand into emerging economies, a key ambition for Singapore banks stuck in a small local market, had also stalled.
India-born Gupta, who had spent 27 years at Citi and is known for having hands-on experience in many parts of the industry, quickly made changes.
One early decision was to beef up transaction banking, a combination of cash management and trade finance that Gupta knew well from his time at Citi. Another was to strengthen wealth management, including through the 2014 acquisition of Societe Generale SA’s Asian private banking arm. The strategy both foresaw and accelerated Singapore’s development as a wealth management hub, the Switzerland of Southeast Asia. In both categories, Gupta built DBS from a low base into a major player in Asia. Both, in turn, strengthened DBS’s advantage at home.
Gupta — a charismatic figure who became a Singapore citizen in 2009 — also started to focus more on technology. This included hiring more engineers and building the bank’s digital offerings. DBS has been investing about S$1 billion ($739 million) annually in technology over the past decade in areas such as cloud computing and artificial intelligence.
In 2021, it was named the world’s best digital bank by Euromoney, a trade publication. The next year, Harvard Business School published a case study on areas including its embrace of digital technology.
But in 2021, DBS suffered its worst outage in a decade, when its online banking services experienced disruptions during the period from Nov. 23 to Nov. 25. In March and May this year, two more incidents angered customers and drew punishment from the regulator. After the May episode, the Monetary Authority of Singapore imposed an additional capital requirement and said the inconvenience caused was “unacceptable.”
Despite vocal public criticism, analysts were largely sanguine. While Kwek said the outages raised some questions about the causes and how to fix them, he thought they weren’t due to Gupta scrimping on IT spending.
Gupta’s track record may provide some explanation for this reaction. Under him, DBS increased return on equity to 15.7% as of March, up from 8.1% in September 2009, just before he took over. HSBC Holdings Plc’s ROE is 13%, Standard Chartered’s is 5.9%, while Citi’s is 7.6%, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
DBS’s stock has gained 141% since the start of November 2009, the month in which Gupta became CEO, compared with a 21% increase for Singapore’s benchmark Straits Times Index. It trades at 1.4 times book value, versus 1.1 times for Oversea-Chinese Banking Corp. and 1 time for United Overseas Bank Ltd., its two local peers. It became Singapore’s largest listed stock in 2017, overtaking Singtel, and its market value is now about S$81 billion.
On the digital outages, Gupta argued the bank’s infrastructure is robust in an interview with Yousef Gamal El-Din at the Dubai FinTech Summit in May. He said penalizing people every time something goes wrong works against building a culture of risk-taking.
Not everyone sees it that way.
“I do think the series of digital disruptions will taint Piyush’s legacy,” said Sarah Jane Mahmud, a Bloomberg Intelligence analyst. “It will be hard to come back from this anytime soon.”
Another criticism of Gupta’s tenure is DBS is still too reliant on Singapore after his years in charge. As of 2022, the city-state contributed close to 65% of the bank’s revenue, broadly similar to when he started. Under Gupta, DBS made acquisitions in India and Taiwan but failed to buy PT Bank Danamon Indonesia in 2013. That may set DBS back by five years in Southeast Asia’s largest economy, he said at the time. DBS spokeswoman Ngui said the bank is growing fast both in Singapore and overseas, and this is a sign of strength.
Tony Fernandes. (Nadirah Zakariya/Bloomberg)
Tony Fernandes, who turned around budget airline AirAsia, focuses on the positives.
He’s “an all-star banker,” said Fernandes, who’s known Gupta since 2003 when the banking executive was Citi’s head for Malaysia. Gupta will stick by clients in tough times, rather than being swayed by short-term risk management, he said. He’s speaking from experience. Like many airlines, AirAsia got into difficulties during the pandemic. “In many cases, it’s risks that run the banks,” Fernandes said. “Piyush has a slightly different opinion.”
Fernandes, himself preparing to step back at AirAsia, said there’s no indication Gupta will retire anytime soon, and DBS won’t be badly affected when he does. But he said a good leader knows when the time has come.
For watchers of Singapore’s biggest bank, the question then will be whether his successor measures up.
