\ Still there is a need for better coordination and greater support of one another.
Even for this loose association, some leadership is required to help establish mutually acceptable ground rules. If you watch Chinese martial art movies, this character called the "武林盟主" probably fits this role perfectly.
bro, my take has changed over time.
all neutrals like harmony unity in the natural but in our context, it is a very unrealistic therefore highly unwise thing to do henceforth.
to me imho, that is the new normal for opposition politics.
why?
1. opp quality too varied
2. in fact traditionally, there has never been unity. pre-election coordination is a laughable uneasy 'division of pork'.
even then, cognitive dissonance can happen - e..g. GMS ongoing grouse against WP in Moulmein-Kallang when he decided to back out - a decision he is free to take or not take.
3. even in JBJ & Chiam's time, are they really that eye-to-eye baring the most minimum of 'opposition solidarity'. basically, they are similar only in anti-PAP, but their political stance very different.
4. today, from SDP's Chee, Dr Ang, Wijey to RP's Kenneth to NSP's GMS & Sebastian Teo to Desmond of SDA and Chiam of SPP ... when should they and how would they even unity ? co-ordinate yes, unite?!
Eventually results are everything.
Low must have realized talk is hollow. Eventually, he just went ahead to execute his own way of building up. From 1991 till now.
the WuXia analogy is apt yet incomplete. Note Nicole Seah's comments on Low you will realise he has commanded certain regard from the younger Opp Aspirants if only based on his 4 continuous success at holding Hougang.
LKY said leadership cannot be arbitrarily appointed - in his context referring to how Cabinet eventually choose their generational Leader to be First amongst Equals.
Likewise in Opposition, Low just let his results speak for itself.
I have high hopes for WP under Low in the years ahead in spite of all the things WP's detractors dwell on.
Low I believe will. in his own way, ensure WP leadership renewal must come to past some day.
Knowing him, he I am sure he doesn't give a shit to GMS's 'advice' or comments...