• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Woke lesbian Bishop gets political during sermon, Trump is pissed

So why need Hadith? N if there are Hadith that contradict the Quran...why is it there in the 1st place? N isn't the Quran perfect n no contradiction n only 1 version n not some eaten by goats n the thousands that memorise it...memorise it correctly etc?
An analogy between the Quran and Hadith is akin to the Constitution and Administrative Rules.

The Constitution set out the Law but the Rules are what defines the nitty gritty details of how to execute the conduct of the Constitution.

Thus the Quran specify the General Law eg the prayer. But it does not spell every detail of how that prayer should be conducted. Otherwise it would be a whole library full of quran.
That detail is covered by the hadiths which is the sayings and examples of the prophet.
 
An analogy between the Quran and Hadith is akin to the Constitution and Administrative Rules.

The Constitution set out the Law but the Rules are what defines the nitty gritty details of how to execute the conduct of the Constitution.

Thus the Quran specify the General Law eg the prayer. But it does not spell every detail of how that prayer should be conducted. Otherwise it would be a whole library full of quran.
That detail is covered by the hadiths which is the sayings and examples of the prophet.
So if the Qur'an is perfect etc n the Hadith's is the administrative rules...than there should be no weak hadiths etc...
 
So if the Qur'an is perfect etc n the Hadith's is the administrative rules...than there should be no weak hadiths etc...
Of course there is. There are many fake Muslims who invent fake hadiths and try to pass it off as what the prophet said or did.
 
When were the hadiths written? Today?
Just like the Quran, hadiths are passed down the generations orally at first and memorized. About 200 years after the prophets death, it was compiled into books.
Fake hadiths started to appear upon the deaths of the four caliphs and as Islam is spreading, enemies of Islam started to claim the prophet did this and that.
 
Just like the Quran, hadiths are passed down the generations orally at first and memorized. About 200 years after the prophets death, it was compiled into books.
Fake hadiths started to appear upon the deaths of the four caliphs and as Islam is spreading, enemies of Islam started to claim the prophet did this and that.


So mudslimes holy book has fake stuff in it...n written down from memory past 200 years....really accurate book
 
Since Day 1 ... Female (Eve) have repeatly screw things up for Man (Adam)
 
Since Day 1 ... Female (Eve) have repeatly screw things up for Man (Adam)
Adam and Eve had two sons, Cain and Abel. They didn't have a daughter. And since she was the only female, she probably fucked her two sons. In order to populate the earth. So not only did she screw up, she also screwed the three men in her life.:biggrin:
 
So mudslimes holy book has fake stuff in it...n written down from memory past 200 years....really accurate book
Only the Quran is holy. It's is divine sent down and unaltered.
The Hadith isn't a holy book. It is a information resource.
Arab culture is heavy on memorization and recitations. Even before the prophet came.
That's why they can narrate stories throughout the course of the night by memory.
 
Only the Quran is holy. It's is divine sent down and unaltered.
The Hadith isn't a holy book. It is a information resource.
Arab culture is heavy on memorization and recitations. Even before the prophet came.
That's why they can narrate stories throughout the course of the night by memory.
Oh yes...and they don't make mistakes etc....from memory...guess to the mudslimes human memory is perfect
 
Oh yes...and they don't make mistakes etc....from memory...guess to the mudslimes human memory is perfect
Because many memorized it, they correct and remind each other.

From Spain Andalusia to Uighurs in China, they all recite from memory and they recite exactly the same. Isn't that the miracle that Allah has promised in the Quran 15:9;

"It is certainly We Who have revealed the Reminder, and it is certainly We Who will preserve it."

You can try to distort, alter, destroy the Quran but since Allah has promised it, you will never be successful. And many have tried.
 
Bitch has been exposed. :cool:

n9MGxfaRP13V.jpeg
 
Back
Top