While there may be some morsel of truth to some of the claims you have made in the above, let me give you a friendly reminder that our scholars are the best people we have, judging from their grades and they have never known failure during their school days. It is impossible to imagine that our scholars and elites fail in any way. They always make the best decisions based on the facts. They must never apologize for changing a strategy or an approach if the facts change.
You are right in saying that they are the best people we have as far as their school grades and school examinations are concerned.
However, in actual world of business, they are not. When compared with those shrewd businessmen who possess good business acumen, they are exam-smart kids.
When doing academic research work, they may make the best decisions based on facts. But in reality, it is doubtful if they make good decisions?
Who made the decision to spend A$400 million to acquire a 12 per cent stake in the ABC Learning Centre owned by the ex-milkman of Brisbane? When the acquisition was made last year, the shares were worth A$7.30 each. The share price plummeted to 54 Australian cents, before the counter was suspended and Temasek Holdings ended up being the biggest losers.
Still remember in mid Sep 08, Oei Hong Leong scooped up shares of the embattled American Insurance Group (AIG) at US$1.80 apiece on the birthday of Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew? On 22 Sep 08, he sold the shares at about US$5 each - a gain of 177 per cent. Oei's perfect timing netted $7m which he donated to Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy.
You put these 2 stories together, do you not think our exam-smart kids pale in comparison..?