It would really be ignorant if to deny that Sim Poh Huat learned from Sim Pooh Ho. In fact Sim Pooh Ho started NWP and the first to teach the Wu Tu Nan sytle in Singapore. I am even doubtful that Sim Poh Huat would deny this.
Boy what a relief! I thot I was dealing with Osama himself.
The question I post is not the relationship between Sim Poh Huat and Sim Pooh Ho, but the legitimacy of Sim Pooh Ho as the close door disciple of Wu Tu Nan as he has claimed.
Since when did I mention Wu Tunan? You brought it in to brown-arm the topic. Shooo!!
For many years Sim Pooh Ho has been promoting his martial arts techniques base on this title. Yet on book published jointly under the name of Ma You Qing and Wu Tu Nan. Wu Tu Nan only recognised Ma as the only close door disciple and Li Jie as the Grand disciple. Not a single word was mentioned about Sim Pooh Ho.
Have you read the original NWP anniversary magazine wherein Wu Tunan wrote a preface complimenting Sim Pooh Ho & acknowledging him as one of his two diciples? Rather old copy & even you had, you will surely deny its existence.
I also have to bless the age of technology, it is so easy to find information. To be honest, I know little about Peter Chong until you mentioned his name, and since you have not at all reveal what Martial Art Association, I got busy and started digging.
How amusing.
There are 2 Peter Chong that interest me, one is a Triad boss in Hong Kong, prominant guy and you can read about him here:
Why even mention this? Wasting bandwidth.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Chong
Adding Singapore to the search give the other Shidan Peter Chong, a Karate expert with many years of experience and wide network world wide. Coincidentally he is also the President of the Singapore Martial Arts
Instructor's Association. The profiles matching your description. The fact that you address him as SinSei support the view that he practises Japanese Martial Arts. Of course you can also read about him here.
Tsk, tsk dun even know Peter Chong - you must be wet behind the ears.
http://www.ikosingapore.com/shihanPeter.php
Then searching for Singapore Martial Arts Instructor's Association gives me the contact:
http://www.smaia.org/about.asp
Checking with them yeild the followings:
1) You can join member by filling the forms and a payment of SGD20;
2) You need to state the Dojo you come from and
your grading in your dojo;
3) The Association will accept your input as it is, they will not make changes unless you up-date them. In fact the person claimed that many just registered and never up-date their particulars for years;
4) The association
never grade the instructors, it is the Dojos who determine their own grading system and grade the instructors accordingly;
Quit wasting my time & bandwidth.
The claim that Master Sim Pooh Ho was awarded a golden belt joint by MA Association and Peter Chong, I have checked up Karate Dan's system which is listed as follows:
J
oint MA Associations back then were very active & you were far too young to know about them. Peter Chong was cited as part of the associations. Read the sentence simply & dun tweak it.
shodan (初段:しょだん): first degree black belt
nidan (二段:にだん): second degree black belt
sandan (三段:さんだん): third degree black belt
yodan (四段:よだん): fourth degree black belt
godan (五段:ごだん): fifth degree black belt
rokudan (六段:ろくだん): sixth degree black belt
nanadan (七段:ななだん): seventh degree black belt (also, shichidan)
hachidan (八段:はちだん): eighth degree black belt
kudan (九段:くだん): ninth degree black belt
jūdan (十段:じゅうだん): tenth degree black belt
Firstly, even for TKD, it is black belt, while Judo white (if my recollection serves me right). The association never grade their members, there is no golden belt from there.
What gibberish vomit! Did I say anything about association grading members?
Secondly, Peter Chong comes from the Karate discipline and there is no correlation between Karate and Taichi, therefore there is no reason for him to gauge whether the "golden belt" (if existed) can be awarded to Sim Pooh Ho.
Again you are twisting around. Did I say PC awarded the golden belt to him? Read again. Deny all you want: golden belt does exist. Again ignorance is a bliss.
The laughable part is your claim that the belt is presented to Sim Pooh Ho jointly by Peter Chong and MA Association,
You are a pathetic fruitcake.
you are telling people that Taichi is of lower standard than Karate and can be graded by Karate Dan standard.
[/B]
That is your absurd assertion, not mine. [/B]
So Sim Pooh Ho must have been learning Karate from Peter Chong. You have just down graded your Grand Master to sub-group of Karate.
Bovine turd excreted from your anus.
Most likely Sim Pooh Ho gave himself the golden belt and registered himself. Other wise you can check up with the association to support your claim.