• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Qoo10 lays off over 80% of Singapore employees amid financial struggles

Hightech88

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
Jul 18, 2014
Messages
4,237
Points
113
No wonder their online site service sucks recently. I ordered one health supplement product from their QOO10 site recently. Big mistrake, as seller bochap delays delivery and no response so I dulan cancelled and request for refund but Seller bochap no response to refund. Chased their helpdesk, says give Seller one more day to respond and must wait til next Mon then they will take action, LOL. Might as well close shop better.
With their financial troubles in paying sellers, think I can kiss my refund goodbye already NBCB.

https://theindependent.sg/qoo10-lays-off-over-80-of-singapore-employees-amid-financial-struggles/

Qoo10 lays off over 80% of Singapore employees amid financial struggles

August 29, 2024

SINGAPORE – In a significant restructuring move, e-commerce platform Qoo10 has laid off more than 80% of its Singapore-based workforce over the past two weeks. Despite the mass retrenchments, the platform continues to operate, although the future remains uncertain.

The layoffs come in the wake of troubling news that Qoo10’s South Korean operations had defaulted on payments to local merchants and consumers. Reports indicate that Singapore employees began receiving notices of possible impacts on the local headquarters shortly after the South Korea news broke late last month.

Speaking to MediaCorp, a retrenched employee revealed that the first batch of layoffs occurred on 13 August, impacting workers from almost all departments, with the exception of the Human Resources team.

“A total of about 90 employees have been affected. Originally, there were 110 employees here. Now, the only ones left are senior management,” the employee stated, emphasizing that the remaining few staff members are solely focused on maintaining the platform’s day-to-day operations.

The retrenched staff reportedly comprised mostly Singapore citizens, with only three foreigners among those affected. According to insiders, Qoo10 expressed regret in letters sent to employees, apologizing for the layoffs and stating that it was not the company’s intention to reduce the workforce.

However, one former employee noted, “There are no benefits after the layoffs because the main reason is that there is really not enough money.”

The atmosphere at Qoo10’s Singapore office reflects the scale of the downsizing. “The two-story office is full of empty desks. If there are really people, there are less than ten,” another former employee remarked, suggesting that the company might be preparing to either sell off its assets or shut down completely.

In response to the situation, Singapore’s Ministry of Manpower confirmed it is closely monitoring developments at Qoo10. The labour movement, while acknowledging that the company is not part of any of its unions, has assured that it will offer support to affected employees if necessary.

For now, Qoo10 continues its operations in Singapore, but the company’s future hangs in the balance as it grapples with financial difficulties.
--------------

https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/e...mplaints-in-south-korea-fears-of-wider-damage

Qoo10 liquidity crisis sparks massive complaints in South Korea, fears of wider damage​


shopping-4694470150.jpg

South Korea online shopping platforms WeMakePrice and Tmon, both owned by Qoo10, have failed to pay money owed to sellers in May. PHOTO ILLUSTRATION: PIXABAY

Tensions are escalating in South Korea over the liquidity crisis of online shopping platforms WeMakePrice and Tmon, both owned by Singapore-based e-commerce company Qoo10, sparking massive complaints and fears of wider damage.

The platforms failed to pay money owed to sellers in May, prompting traders to leave the platform. There are complaints from customers as well.

In an urgent press conference on July 25, Mr Ryu Hwan-hyun, chief executive of WeMakePrice, said the value of delayed payments by the company was some 4 billion won (S$3.9 million).

“We offer a deep apology for the delayed payments,” he said at the company headquarters in southern Seoul, where hundreds of consumers had gathered all night to demand compensation. “Qoo10 Group has been working to secure funds to pay sellers.”

Mr Ryu vowed all-out efforts to reduce additional losses in close consultation with Tmon and Qoo10.

“I arrived here today at 8am to receive the compensation. But nothing has progressed after spending nine hours here,” said Mr Park, a 37-year-old Seoul resident. He added that he was unable to get a refund for a travel package he purchased for his family’s vacation scheduled for August in the Philippines, totalling around 2 million won.

“It’s disappointing that all I could hear from the service providers, including the travel agencies and WeMakePrice, is that they can do nothing except tell me to apply for a refund and wait indefinitely,” he said.


Ms Kim Seo-hyun, a 42-year-old mother who had planned to visit a theme park with her son and daughter, criticised the company’s poor handling of the situation at the site.

“When I first arrived this morning, a company official said that those who signed for the refund by filling out a document would receive the refunds first and that we could go home after completing the documentation,” she said.

“But nothing happened. The procedures abruptly changed to an online system where consumers apply for refunds via a QR code, and I received no notice from the company.”

Qoo10 acquired WeMakePrice and Tmon in 2022 and 2023, respectively.

According to market tracker Wiseapp Retail Goods, transactions made on Tmon and WeMakePrice were estimated at 839.8 billion won and 308.2 billion won, respectively, with 4.37 million and 4.32 million monthly users.

Regulators were also ramping up efforts to monitor the situation. The nation’s antitrust watchdog, the Fair Trade Commission, said it started on-site inspections to prevent further losses.

Meanwhile, industry experts suggest that the business disruptions likely occurred because Qoo10 might have used the delayed payments to expand its business with the apparent goal of listing on the stock market in New York.
Earlier in February, Qoo10 acquired American e-commerce platform Wish for 230 billion won. It also acquired another Korean e-commerce platform, AK Mall, in March.

“When Qoo10 acquired Tmon and WeMakePrice, it used Qxpress shares instead of money. However, for the Wish acquisition, it had to pay in cash. There are speculations among industry insiders that Qoo10 diverted funds from Tmon and WeMakePrice for the acquisition,” an industry official who wished to remain anonymous said. Qxpress is a logistics company focused on e-commerce.

The official added that Tmon and WeMakePrice were already struggling financially due to an increasingly competitive market environment. Regulatory filings show that Tmon’s cash reserves were 8 billion won as of 2022, down from 55.5 billion won the previous year, while WeMakePrice’s impaired capital reached 239.8 billion won.

Another source pointed out that the main problem was the lack of legal standards for the settlement cycle.

“It has been reported that Tmon and WeMakePrice have frequently failed to meet payment settlement dates for sellers since last year, especially around October, when Qoo10 announced it would delay payment dates by two months,” the source said.

Unlike Tmon and WeMakePrice, most e-commerce platforms here, including Auction, Gmarket, Naver Storefarm and 11Street, pay sellers upon consumer purchase confirmation. Coupang, however, takes around one to two months to settle payments.

The source also suggested that the issue centred around travel packages and gift certificates because these items typically have higher transaction values and do not require immediate physical delivery, making it easier for Tmon and WeMakePrice to use them to secure extra cash reserves immediately.

In the meantime, some retailers, including bakery giant SPC Group, have announced they will share the financial damage by offering refunds to customers for purchased products. THE KOREA HERALD/ASIA NEWS NETWORK
-------------
 
Ok lah. Only coolie gene Sinkies impacted. Remesh and country men are fine.
 
Last edited:
OMG...are they qualified for $6000 in Apr 2025?
 
The labour movement, while acknowledging that the company is not part of any of its unions, has assured that it will offer support to affected employees if necessary.
Lol if the labour union still needs to think if it’s necessary to offer support to retrenched employees, then we know what that means!
 
Ng Chee Ming told the staff that Singapore salary is too high and that is why retrenchment is high
 
OMG...are they qualified for $6000 in Apr 2025?
Govt seems to be expecting wave of retrenchment in advance
Wonder behind closed doors, how do they discuss with the industry leaders
Beg them not to announce too early, wait after NDR :biggrin:
 
Looks like really up lorry. Better don't buy anything from there. Luckily I got my refund last week, phew!..LOL.

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/sin...ion-payment-delays-sellers-businesses-4603196

Police investigating e-commerce platform Qoo10 over payment delays to vendors​

12 Sep 2024 02:51PM(Updated: 12 Sep 2024 03:58PM)

Some frustrated merchants filed claims with a tribunal, while others have stopped selling products on Qoo10.

SINGAPORE: The police are investigating Singapore-based e-commerce platform Qoo10 after local businesses were hit by payment delays, prompting some frustrated vendors to turn to a claims tribunal to seek help.

Signs of trouble emerged in July when two of Qoo10's Seoul-based platforms failed to make payments to merchants in South Korea. The two platforms - TMON and WeMakePrice - later filed for corporate rehabilitation in the Seoul Bankruptcy Court.

South Korean financial authorities have launched an investigation.

In response to CNA's queries, the Singapore Police Force said on Thursday (Sep 12) that reports were lodged against Qoo10 and investigations are ongoing.

Mr Liu Wei Guo, a vendor who has been using Qoo10 since 2014 to sell baby and maternity products, was among those who made a police report after payment delays dragged on.

According to Mr Liu, it usually takes two to three weeks for payment to reach him, but it has been almost two months since he asked to withdraw around S$21,000 (US$16,100) worth of sales proceeds from his Qoo10 seller account. The request was made on Jul 19 and the due date for the money to come through had been set on Aug 5.

The money from subsequent requests has also not landed in his bank account.

In addition, Mr Liu said Qoo10 is also holding in escrow more than S$11,000 worth of his sales proceeds that it has not made available for him to withdraw.

Of the 11 vendors CNA spoke to, eight confirmed that they were still waiting for the money Qoo10 owed them. Some are waiting for a few hundred dollars while others are owed thousands.

One vendor who had been waiting for payments he requested on Aug 18 and Sep 1 was paid on Tuesday night.

BUSINESSES STOP SELLING ON QOO10​

Qoo10 was one of the first e-commerce platforms in Singapore when online shopping gained popularity.

On its website, Qoo10 describes itself as Asia's leading online marketplace that operates in five markets in the region.

As the payment delays continue, several vendors - big and small - have pulled products from the platform.

They include popular brands such as instant beverage retailer Gold Kili. An employee said the company decided to discontinue its service on Qoo10 due to a “dispute”, although she declined to specify what the dispute was.

Fragrance, which sells bak kwa and other local snacks, has also removed products for sale on its Qoo10 page.

“While we prefer not to comment further on Qoo10 payment matters at this time, we will continue to monitor the situation and await more information from Qoo10,” Fragrance told CNA, adding that orders that had already been placed will be fulfilled.

An employee of Lao Ban Niang, which offers a variety of traditional Chinese medicine and foodstuff, said it had also stopped taking orders on Qoo10 due to the payment delays.

FRUSTRATED VENDORS FILE CLAIMS​

Perhaps harder hit are smaller vendors, some of whom have turned to the Small Claims Tribunals of the State Courts to try and get their money back.

Ms Angela Lee, the operations manager of Amberlys Cakes & Flowers, has been waiting for payments requested in July, August and September. In total, the unfulfilled withdrawals amount to about S$2,400.

She filed a small claim against Qoo10 in late August.

Vendors CNA spoke to said they tried to reach the company via email, only to receive a generic response with no clear indication of when the payment would be made.

Mr Liu, for instance, sent four emails to Qoo10. The amount the platform owes him is too large to file a small claim so he made a police report in late August.

The issue has prompted Workers' Party Member of Parliament Louis Chua to file a parliamentary question asking if Singapore authorities are investigating the matter.

Minister for Trade and Industry Gan Kim Yong said in his reply on Tuesday that the government received feedback from several merchants about payment delays.

“We have brought these cases to Qoo10’s attention and requested that they take prompt action to resolve the delays with the affected merchants,” he said.

“The government is also closely monitoring developments in South Korea regarding Qoo10’s subsidiaries and is in touch with Qoo10 to assess whether and how this may affect its operations in Singapore.”

Qoo10 did not respond to CNA’s emails for comment. Calls to its office number went unanswered.

When CNA visited the building where the company is located, this reporter was not allowed to go up to Qoo10’s office on the 18th floor on Wednesday. A receptionist said Qoo10 recently asked the building’s management not to allow any visitors to its office.

LOSS OF ACCOUNT MANAGERS​

This is not the first time Qoo10 merchants have faced payment delays.

Some of them said they experienced a similar situation at the beginning of 2023 but the recent news in South Korea has fuelled worries.

“You can actually see from the news reports (in South Korea) that there are people lining up, practically at the door, to get back the money,” said Ms Lee of Amberlys Cakes & Flowers.

“So it picks up the fear.”

Adding to the uncertainty, vendors said their Qoo10 account managers have left the company.

Mr Samuel Lim, who runs two businesses on Qoo10 and is waiting for several payments, said he was previously able to discuss the 2023 issues with his account manager and get some resolution.

“Now that both my Qoo10 account managers have resigned, we got no other ways,” he said.

Mr Clarence Tey, who sells cosmetics on Qoo10, also said he reached out to his account manager when he faced delays, only to realise she was leaving Qoo10.

Mandarin news platform Channel 8 recently reported that Qoo10 had laid off 80 per cent of its employees in mid-August.

Qoo10 did not respond to CNA’s questions about the job losses.

The Manpower Ministry's Taskforce for Responsible Retrenchment and Employment Facilitation said on Aug 28 that it was monitoring the retrenchment exercise.

Singapore's labour movement noted that Qoo10 is a non-unionised company but said it stands ready to offer support and resources where possible to help displaced workers.

“NOT MUCH HELP”​

Dozens of unpaid vendors have turned to a WhatsApp chat group to discuss ways to resolve the issue, although some feel their options are limited.

“For sellers ... there's actually not much help for situations like this,” said Mr Adrian, who asked to be known only by his first name for business reasons.

“There’s so many (merchants affected), but nobody seems to be able to do anything.”

In his response to Tuesday's parliamentary question, Mr Gan said merchants facing payment delays should raise their concerns with Qoo10.

“If the concerns remain unresolved, there are established processes in place to assist merchants in resolving commercial disputes, inclusive of debt recovery,” he added.

“Merchants who face cash flow difficulties because of the payment delays may contact any of the participating Financial Institutions listed on Enterprise Singapore’s website to apply for the Enterprise Financing Scheme (Working Capital Loan).”

When asked if they would continue using Qoo10 if it resolved this round of delays, vendors had mixed responses.

Mr Tey said he doubts he would continue selling unless there was news that the platform was financially stable.

QH, the operations manager of a mask-selling business called Wistech Singapore, said they would continue using the platform if it resolves the payment delays.

Several longtime sellers on the platform noted that Qoo10 has served them well until the payment delays.

“It’s a bit wasted, you know,” said Ms Lee.

“We also don’t want to break off unless there is no alternative. But it is physically and mentally draining to chase money every other month,” she added.

“Other platforms all provide better payback arrangements.”
------------------------
 
I don't understand. Do they have to hold the goods title in order to sell or suppliers just consign their goods for them to sell? If it is the latter, like this also can screw up?
 
This kind of CB platform go and die lah..... should have uplorry long ago.... who will still even bother selling their products and then payment delay and delay until later go missing........ it's liken to giving them your goods lor..... you wait hor wait huh.... KNN....
 
All the 'middleman' online shopping portals will eventually die out. Each brand/company will have its own online shopping platform. The remaining market share will go to Amazon, which will return to its roots: selling books, only this time it is also selling Amazon Prime subscriptions.

As China descends into economic irrelevancy, all of the Tiong platforms (Taobao, Teemu etc) will go out of business, Same for the Tiong-affliated local ones: Lazada and Shopee.
 
Back
Top