• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Chitchat PUB's revisionist history on flash flood

scroobal

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
25,132
Points
83
Saw PUB's explanation about flash floods and the work that they did over the decades to reduce flood prone areas from 32,000 hectares to 30 hectares. Plus their mention of current 100 odd flood prone and flash flood hotspots.

Surely an entire statutory board created and regulated by parliament cannot be this dishonest. I am not sure if we are dealing with institutional memory loss by choice.

Let get back to our very recent history - 16 Jun 2010 when Orchard Road and the whole of Singapore saw first wide spread flooding after nearly 2 decades. 2 days later on 18th June PUB supposed traced the cause of the flood to a blocked underground culvert in front of Delphi which cause Stamford Canal to overflow and flood Orchard Road. And here is their statement from one of their head honchos on the same day.

"Capacity wasn't a factor at all, as there were similar storms in the past and the canal handled such storms."

2 years prior to the first of Orchard Road floods, Marina Barrage - a dam was completed to create a reservoir plus to handle floods.

So what went wrong? The first Minister who had responsibility for this claimed it was a 100 year event, the second promptly classified it was ponding.

PUB for nearly 40 years was one of the best run Govt entities and in first 30 years was the largest contributor to Consolidated Fund. It also built a cadre of well respected Engineers for the country's power stations, Gas works and the most importantly water and flood control. All gone to the dogs.
 
PUB is not in charge of historical archiving and history writing. You do not expect PUB to do everything.
 
Saw PUB's explanation about flash floods and the work that they did over the decades to reduce flood prone areas from 32,000 hectares to 30 hectares. Plus their mention of current 100 odd flood prone and flash flood hotspots.

Surely an entire statutory board created and regulated by parliament cannot be this dishonest. I am not sure if we are dealing with institutional memory loss by choice.

Let get back to our very recent history - 16 Jun 2010 when Orchard Road and the whole of Singapore saw first wide spread flooding after nearly 2 decades. 2 days later on 18th June PUB supposed traced the cause of the flood to a blocked underground culvert in front of Delphi which cause Stamford Canal to overflow and flood Orchard Road. And here is their statement from one of their head honchos on the same day.

"Capacity wasn't a factor at all, as there were similar storms in the past and the canal handled such storms."

2 years prior to the first of Orchard Road floods, Marina Barrage - a dam was completed to create a reservoir plus to handle floods.

So what went wrong? The first Minister who had responsibility for this claimed it was a 100 year event, the second promptly classified it was ponding.

PUB for nearly 40 years was one of the best run Govt entities and in first 30 years was the largest contributor to Consolidated Fund. It also built a cadre of well respected Engineers for the country's power stations, Gas works and the most importantly water and flood control. All gone to the dogs.

Why are you so shocked by the dishonest lies coming from PUB. WHo is their CEO? Non other then former Scholar Police Commissioner Ng Joo Hee. What does this fucker know about engineering and PUB responsibilities? The lancheow can't even run the police properly. After the Little India riot and the COI, he was moved out to PUB. All they do at the Police force is spin stories for their incompetence. He just carries that to the PUB. Then you got other shits like Low yen Ling, Perm Sec for MOE and MITI and Mayor, and Eric Lian (Director for Stomachsick Holdings). What do these fucktards know about public utilities?
 
Saw PUB's explanation about flash floods and the work that they did over the decades to reduce flood prone areas from 32,000 hectares to 30 hectares. Plus their mention of current 100 odd flood prone and flash flood hotspots.

I bet they are still trying to soak in the theme of nostalgia after SG50.
 
I forgot about Ng Joo Hee. This guy despite his humble roots in Tanglin Halt has lived a charmed life. He literally asked and got whatever assignments he wanted. One of the laziest person there is. I don't think there there is anyone that worked for him has anything good to say about this guy.

Why are you so shocked by the dishonest lies coming from PUB. WHo is their CEO? Non other then former Scholar Police Commissioner Ng Joo Hee. What does this fucker know about engineering and PUB responsibilities? The lancheow can't even run the police properly. After the Little India riot and the COI, he was moved out to PUB. All they do at the Police force is spin stories for their incompetence. He just carries that to the PUB. Then you got other shits like Low yen Ling, Perm Sec for MOE and MITI and Mayor, and Eric Lian (Director for Stomachsick Holdings). What do these fucktards know about public utilities?
 
Let's hope for another flash flood today. HUAT ah! :D
Drown all the roaches in Orchard Road! See if they can picnic in the rain.
 
I forgot about Ng Joo Hee. This guy despite his humble roots in Tanglin Halt has lived a charmed life. He literally asked and got whatever assignments he wanted. One of the laziest person there is. I don't think there there is anyone that worked for him has anything good to say about this guy.

That is understandable, not many people know that Ng Joo Hee was moved to PUB. I mean it was announced but very quiet and very little fanfare. Punishment for LI.
 
Yes, I remember very clearly the "blocked culvert" excuse. Apparently there are many, many blocked culverts that have gone undetected or unrepaired because after the famous 2010 orchard road flooding, the supposed "once in 50-years event" kept on recurring with surprising frequency.

PUB thinks Singaporeans have extremely short memories, and they can't be blamed because they are part of a government machinery that has successfully used collective amnesia to win elections and persecute political opponents without the slightest repercussion.

Nobody however remembers such regular flooding before 2010, or before the Marina Barrage was constructed. Floods were rare, and when they did happen, the next occurrence was not tomorrow or next week but years later.

All this while, Singapore has also become a very densely built city, so the latest reasoning that of "PONDING" being a result of urbanization holds no water.

How silly and dishonest can the govt be, to actually claim that our high built-up density is key factor. Who in his right mind will believe such a blatant lie?

And yet they continue to lie and give excuses, and year after year, every time the monsoon season hits or everytime the rain is especially heavy, the inevitable flooding occurs.

No one in govt even dares to mention the near perfect correlation between increased flood occurrence and Marina Barrage. Not a soul! Who dares to offend the Lee family? Yep I didn't think so.
 
I forgot about Ng Joo Hee. This guy despite his humble roots in Tanglin Halt has lived a charmed life. He literally asked and got whatever assignments he wanted. One of the laziest person there is. I don't think there there is anyone that worked for him has anything good to say about this guy.

Every top government scholar deserves a charmed life. Why else do you think so many parents including myself spend so much money on spending our kids to the best schools and hiring tutors?
 
Back
Top