One of many: This Malaysian Chinese got 9As for SPM, excelled in extracurriculars & still couldn’t get a scholarship from JPA
Coconuts KL
Tue, 3 January 2023 at 5:37 am GMT·3-min read
It’s a known fact that Malaysia has been facing a severe brain drain for decades now. It is estimated that
around 500,000 highly-skilled Malaysians are working abroad.
In a post on the r/Malaysia subreddit titled “
Is it true that Malaysia purposely drains the brain drain…? Or there’s a rationale behind it“, local Redditors gathered to share their experiences – and also call people out – based on a TikTok video that has been trending recently.
TikTok user @jessica_sin shared quite lengthily about her experience of not being able to receive a scholarship from the Public Service Department (JPA) for overseas study, despite excelling in both academia and extracurricular activities during high school.
A JPA scholarship programme covers local preparatory studies until degree level in a government, government-linked or private institution based on the guidelines and conditions prepared by JPA.
For context, the scholarship also has a quota for each race like Bumiputera, Chinese and Indian. JPA prioritises giving Bumiputera more allocation.
In the video, Jessica lamented that she was unhappy with the racial discrimination in Malaysia, especially when it came to education and opportunities.
“Like for my SPM in 2010, I got 9A+ for all core subjects. I was very active in extracurricular activities, having held leadership roles, and also represented my school in various English and Math competitions.”
“But when I went to apply JPA scholarship from the Ministry of Education, they rejected my overseas scholarship application and I found out that Bumiputeras get overseas scholarships in developed countries for 4-5 years even when they only scored a few As,” she said.
“Now, I acknowledge Bumiputeras have special rights but that doesn’t mean you don’t recognise those of other races when they put in the effort,” she said.
She added that while Malaysia rejected her, universities in Australia and the United States offered her full scholarships without bond.
“And you wonder why so many talented Malaysians move abroad. Look at the state of the Malaysian economy, foreign investors pulling out, and RM is dropping to a low rate, especially against USD and SGD, talent is moving abroad and we are falling behind.”
“If we want our country to prosper and improve, we need to appreciate people that can contribute,” she said.
The human flight and brain drain index, for which data is available from 2007 to 2020, suggests the situation has been on the rise throughout the period.
Based on its surveys, in 2009 the World Bank reported a serious shortage of high technical skills in Malaysia, including among fresh graduates, thus reflecting serious problems within the education system. This dynamic continued well into 2015 and remains to this day.
Some Redditors reacted to the video and shared their own similar experiences while others speculated the reason behind Malaysia’s brain drain.