• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Page One next bookstore to close in S'pore?

Alamaking

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
Joined
Aug 6, 2008
Messages
19,724
Points
83
After Borders closed its two stores in Singapore recently, home-grown bookshop Page One could be next.

PageOne may shut down its VivoCity branch in March next year because of losses even as it has scheduled to open two stores in Beijing in the coming months, reported The Straits Times.

"The store has been making a loss of between $600,000 and $800,000 a year since it opened in 2006, but I want to continue as long as I can stomach the loss," said Page One chief executive Mark Tan.
The VivoCity lease has been extended from next month to March as the store's management negotiates for a lower rent.

Brick-and-mortar bookshops have struggled to stay afloat in recent times amid competition from online retailers and changes in consumer habits.

In Singapore, at least six bookstores have closed since 2009, including the flagship outlet of The Commercial Press, the city-state's oldest Chinese bookshop.

This was though local retail sales of books, newspapers and stationery rose 17 per cent in 2009 from two years before, based on the latest figures of the Singapore Department of Statistics.

Tan pointed out that although Page One's book sales in Singapore have grown by a single-digit rate each year, income has been destroyed by increasing rents.

In May, bookstore chain MPH chose not to renew its least at Novena Square because it could not match the rental offer made by prospective food and beverage tenants which was double the store's original rent, the same paper reported.
 
It will be sad to see another mega-bookshop going for good.

It's orgasmic enough by just smelling fresh prints of paper in your hands.

Enough of those eateries.
 
Can stomach 800k loss per yr for 5 yrs............He must be damn rich or damn passionate !

it a 4 million loss !!!





After Borders closed its two stores in Singapore recently, home-grown bookshop Page One could be next.

PageOne may shut down its VivoCity branch in March next year because of losses even as it has scheduled to open two stores in Beijing in the coming months, reported The Straits Times.

"The store has been making a loss of between $600,000 and $800,000 a year since it opened in 2006, but I want to continue as long as I can stomach the loss," said Page One chief executive Mark Tan.
The VivoCity lease has been extended from next month to March as the store's management negotiates for a lower rent.

Brick-and-mortar bookshops have struggled to stay afloat in recent times amid competition from online retailers and changes in consumer habits.

In Singapore, at least six bookstores have closed since 2009, including the flagship outlet of The Commercial Press, the city-state's oldest Chinese bookshop.

This was though local retail sales of books, newspapers and stationery rose 17 per cent in 2009 from two years before, based on the latest figures of the Singapore Department of Statistics.

Tan pointed out that although Page One's book sales in Singapore have grown by a single-digit rate each year, income has been destroyed by increasing rents.

In May, bookstore chain MPH chose not to renew its least at Novena Square because it could not match the rental offer made by prospective food and beverage tenants which was double the store's original rent, the same paper reported.
 
Page One is an unusual store. From the very start you knew that it was not going to make money because many of the books were of an esoteric nature. Great place to browse as you could find stuff that others did not have. Used to see a lot of dignitaries browsing the shelves. I got the impression that the owner liked books more than money. The layout was so bad that you had to go thru a maze to get to some books and you could never return to same spot at the next attempt.
 
This is one true blue passionate employer who also good to his staff. SG needs more of these kinda people. But too bad our screwed up goberment only know how to support FTs. Even if he is a FT, its the kind SG needs. Its sad to see these kind of businessman fail.
 
Book store and CD store in Singapore will never make money ..it's sad .
 
Right.

Best business in Sg is fuck shop and eat shop.

Consumers don't care about things other than those that bring instant satisfaction. Books for most are history once exams are over.

Why should I give a fuck?

Cheers!
 
Book store and CD store in Singapore will never make money ..it's sad .
Kinokuniya at Bugis and Takashimaya still there and hope it will be. Never fail to visit Kinokuniya when I am in SG.

Right.

Best business in Sg is fuck shop and eat shop.

Consumers don't care about things other than those that bring instant satisfaction. Books for most are history once exams are over.

Why should I give a fuck?

Cheers!
Used to think the same until I cross the 40s mark. Never appreciate books during my younger days but now wished I had read more.
 
Page One is the reason why I go to Vivocity, hope it won't close down
 
In the past, MPH and Times dominated the bookshop scene. Both matied years ago. Borders dieded very recently. Looks like the easiest way to lose $ is to go into bookshop biz.
 
It is not only in Singapore but the world over. Over the years, many of the well known bookstores have begun selling stationeries, sweets and even sandwiches and that space is growing bigger at the expense of books. WHSmith is a classic case.
 
In the past, MPH and Times dominated the bookshop scene. Both matied years ago. Borders dieded very recently. Looks like the easiest way to lose $ is to go into bookshop biz.

How come Popular still expanding?
 
Mark's brother is an architect. they started out with esoteric books on architecture and interior designs, renting space from Kinokuniya. Later, Mark got to know a Japanese professional photographer who was browsing thru his store. The guy was a sort of globe trotter who loved to shoot travel pics and street scenes involving people and surroundings from very interesting angles. So they got to talk and started discussing a joint partnership where the Jap guy would shoot the stunning photos and Mark and his bro would incorporate them in books and published them for very special clientele who looked for these books. Soon he also roped in his family members to chip in and for a while they made some splash in Taipei at the taipei 101 tower when it first opened. They also had plans to open in Dubai, and China, always looking out for the firstest, bestest, spankiest, mammothest mega mall to open in. From where I got to know them, for Mark (as Scroobal said) the bookstore was more of a hobbyhorse than hard-headed cash cow. I think cashflow ran out faster than his vision, as his eyes were bigger than his stomach, so to speak. But Mark was a really nice chap, passionate about his work, and very personable and modest.


Page One is an unusual store. From the very start you knew that it was not going to make money because many of the books were of an esoteric nature. Great place to browse as you could find stuff that others did not have. Used to see a lot of dignitaries browsing the shelves. I got the impression that the owner liked books more than money. The layout was so bad that you had to go thru a maze to get to some books and you could never return to same spot at the next attempt.
 
Actually, even the layout was fastidiously designed. That 'falling down' look with the slanting bookshelves was deliberate to create that arty crafty nouveau arts haute culture flavour.

But alas! all good things come to an end.


The layout was so bad that you had to go thru a maze to get to some books and you could never return to same spot at the next attempt.
 
Last edited:
Assessment books and stationery are their cash cows.

Never seen any freeloader browsing through an assessment book for pleasure.

Popular have gone into property as well.
Father and son had a falling out recently. Son quit as CEO.
I actually have respect for these 2 men.
Son willing to stand up to father.
Father willing to let son find his own way.
 
Never go in Page One before. From outside already look like selling arty farty books. My favourite is always Popular since schooldays. Everything can get there. No need other bookshops LOL
 
Never go in Page One before. From outside already look like selling arty farty books. My favourite is always Popular since schooldays. Everything can get there. No need other bookshops LOL

Yah, all you need nowadays is a 10 year series :)
 
Back
Top