Is it an offense to lie in Singapore?
THE authorities had assured him that commercial firms could bid for land marked for religious purposes, said the Member of Parliament at the forefront of the Sengkang columbarium controversy.
That is why he defended the tender in a dialogue with residents earlier this month, said Sengkang West MP Lam Pin Min in an interview with The Straits Times yesterday.
But it was revealed in Parliament on Thursday that, unlike previous bidders, funeral service provider Eternal Pure Land (EPL) did not have any religious links.
"I... asked HDB and URA whether a commercial entity is allowed to participate in a tender process for a place of worship, and I was informed that it had been done before," he said, referring to the Housing Board and the Urban Redevelopment Authority.
Previous tenders by commercial players had been affiliated to a religious organisation but EPL is a pure profit company.
"EPL told us that they were in the process of discussing with some religious organisation to work out some of the temple- related activities," he added.
The Government has since admitted that it was a mistake to award the tender to EPL.
National Development Minister Khaw Boon Wan said on Thursday that the ministry would stop the commercial columbarium.
The authorities will also review the tender process to plug this loophole where commercial firms muscle into places of worship.
The decision has been cheered by Dr Lam, who is also the Minister of State for Health.
He has been feeling the heat from some residents and netizens since news of the planned columbarium broke a month back. They were upset that a site planned for a Chinese temple would also have a columbarium, especially one operated for commercial interests.
They started an online petition against it, garnering more than 1,000 signatures. It prompted Dr Lam to hold a dialogue on Jan 4.
But at the session, he was perceived to be defending EPL rather than siding with his constituents. Some pointed out that he was sitting at the same table as representatives from Life Corporation - the parent firm of EPL. They were also unhappy that he highlighted the modern look of the temple.
Dr Lam clarified yesterday that he had not been taking sides and he did not understand why the seating arrangements had become an issue. "My purpose there was first to facilitate the dialogue session, to clarify the misinformation of what was posted online, and to allow residents to raise their concerns to me and the relevant agencies," he said.
"Usually for a dialogue session, this is how it's done."
He said he did not scrutinise whether a commercial entity which bid for land for places of worship had to have religious ties.
He was not aware of the rules and was not part of the tender process, he said, adding that the rules had "very fine details".
Asked if it had been a stressful time for him, he replied: "Definitely. No one wants anything to happen in their constituency."
He said the residents were relieved that action had been taken. "I'm just happy that a decision has been made... to not have a commercial columbarium there.
"I'm also just happy that many of the residents who are concerned can have their fears allayed because, at the end of the day, this is a positive outcome for many of the residents."
The word PTE LTD on Eternal Pure Land PTE LTD means this company is a commercial entity . Why should the authority assume a PTE LTD got anything to do with religious organization? Why don't KBW comes clean instead of telling fairy tale. There is no reason for HDB and URA not to be awared of it.
Really, No one wants anything to happen in their constituency.
Last I known Lam Pin Min was defending the building of the columbarium.
It was Worker's Party Lee Li Lian who raise this in parliament.
To the residents of Sengkang West, it should be clear by now in whose interest did Lam Pin Min served.
So many ministers of state and “talents” but all were “fooled” by Life Corp?
Ladies and Gentlemen, introducing the cast of “The Butterfly Lovers – Singapore Style”, as narrated by Khaw Boon Wan:
1. Khaw Boon Wan, Minister for National Development
2. Unidentified man/woman
And supporting cast (from left to right):
1. Desmond Lee, Minister of State, MND
2. Dr Mohamad Maliki, Minister of State, MND
3. Ng Lang, URA CEO
4. Lee Hsien Loong, Prime Minister
5. Dr Cheong Koon Hean, HDB CEO
6. Lee Yi Shyan, Senior Minister of State, MND
7. Lam Pin Min, MP Sengkang West SMC
Print your own poster from here:
http://www.tremeritus.com/2015/01/31/alamak-we-have-all-been-tricked/
http://singaporedesk.blogspot.sg/2015/01/life-and-death-links.html
The chart above shows that Life Corporation Ltd's (LCL) original business line of cord blood storage wasn't doing too well. Lots more can be gleaned from its 2014 Annual Report filed with the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX).
Armed with A$5.5 million from the June 2013 sale of its cord blood and cord tissue banking businesses and assets in India, the Philippines, Hong Kong and Indonesia to Singapore Stock Exchange (SGX) listed Cordlife Group Limited, LCL quickly bought up Singapore Funeral Services (known as SFS Care Pte Ltd since 2012) in September 2013. The chronology that led to the formation of Eternal Pure Land Pte Ltd (EPL) is spelt out in the annual report:
1 Dec 2013, SFS acquired;
8 Jun 2014, tender submitted;
17 Jul 2014, tender awarded;
22 Jul 2014, bonds signed with "Golden Meditech" and "Northeast" for S$3 million each, funds which may come in handy for the two installments due on 13 August and 14 October 2014.
The most interesting date is 12 June 2014, day when EPL was set up to bid for the land parcel at Sengkang, a newborn with no track record, and only the operating experience of the Singapore entity, Singapore Funeral Services.
LCL's consolidated revenue for year ended 30 Jun 2014 was only A$1,907,000, of which A$1,905,000 was contributed by SFS Care Pte Ltd. Net loss for LCL was A$2,637,000, an increase of 61% compared to the loss of A$1,640,00 for year ended 30 Jun 2013.
You have to wonder what were on the minds of the civil servants when they evaluated the bidders. For all we know, some name dropper may have casually made it be known that Goh Chok Tong's son is on the board of Cordlife. Dr Goh Jin Hian was appointed as a Director of the Company in July 2011. It is ironical that the science of cord blood banking, preservation of cord blood to help nurture life in the future, is now linked to the preservation of ashes, after science has given up on saving life.
There is more to the eye at Sengkang, it's not just "commercial" and "religious" issues at stake. It's so serious, LCL has called for a trading halt after Khaw Boon Wan told the story of deception by Butterfly Lover Zhu Yingtai. As usual, to find the answer to the quagmire, one has to follow the money.
No wonder the $2 company got the tender! No cronyism? No Meleetocracy? *PUI*
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goh_Chok_Tong
[h=2]Family[edit][/h]Goh is married to Tan Choo Leng and they have a son and a daughter, who are twins. Their son, Goh Jin Hian, is a medical doctor and their daughter, Goh Jin Theng, is in London with her English husband, Lee Craven.