http://motoring.asiaone.com/Motoring/Motorworld/Others/Story/A1Story20090223-123871.html
Lowered fares but he pays more
I AM writing to praise the decision SBS Transit and SMRT took to reduce public-transport fares from April 1.
After going through and understanding the new fare structure and transfer-rebate scheme, I can see that SBS Transit and SMRT took time and effort to implement the changes.
It is a good idea to lower fares across the board by 2 cents.
While the amount might not be much, it at least shows that public-transport operators are doing something to ease commuters' load during the global financial crunch.
The move to raise the transfer-rebate limit to a maximum of 50 cents is also very welcome.
However, the new fare structure might lead to higher fares for some commuters, compared to fares under the old structure.
The problem lies in the calculation of the new transfer rebates, whereby rebate amounts rise with the number of transfers, which is set at a maximum of three.
Have SBS Transit and SMRT ever considered the number of commuters who need to do three transfers on an average day?
I believe most commuters will make either one or two transfers.
As for me, based on the current fare structure, the cost of my single trip from my home to my workplace can be broken down as follows:
Buangkok station to HarbourFront station - $1.73
HarbourFront station to bus stop before the Agri-Food & Veterinary Authority - $0.71
Transfer rebate - $0.40
Final fare - $2.04
Under the new fare structure, it would be:
Buangkok station to HarbourFront station - $1.71
HarbourFront station to bus stop before the Agri-Food & Veterinary Authority - $0.69
Transfer rebate - $0.14
Final fare - $2.26
As shown above, the new fare structure does not help me cut my monthly public-transport expenses.
I hope public-transport operators and the Public Transport Council will relook the new fare structure, as it may not help some commuters reduce their transport costs.
Mr Lee Kok Hiong