In China, 500 retweets could mean three years in prison

[CuttingItFine]

In China, 500 retweets could mean three years in prison

Tough anti-defamation laws aim to stem the spread of online rumors

By Amar Toor on September 9, 2013 07:41am

The Chinese government today announced harsh new anti-defamation laws designed to stem the spread of online rumors. As Reuters reports, users who post false rumors that are widely circulated on the internet will face up to three years in jail — the standard sentence for violating China's defamation laws.

In a ruling handed down Monday, China's high court determined that people whose rumors are reposted at least 500 times or viewed at least 5,000 times would be liable for prosecution.

"People have been hurt and reaction in society has been strong, demanding with one voice serious punishment by the law for criminal activities like using the internet to spread rumors and defame people," court spokesman Sun Jungong told reporters. "No country would consider the slander of other people as 'freedom of speech.'"

""People have been hurt and reaction in society has been strong.""

Today's announcement marks the latest in China's ongoing campaign to crack down on social media sites such as Sina Weibo, the country's Twitter equivalent. Beijing has long held tight control over its domestic internet, but the government has ramped up its efforts as of late, following a spate of embarrassing political scandals.

Several prominent officials have been forced to resign in recent months, including Yang Dacai, who last week was sentenced to 14 years in prison after web users posted pictures of him wearing expensive watches. The images led to a corruption inquiry and spurred President Xi Jinping to launch a widespread anti-bribery campaign.

Under Monday's ruling, a "serious case" of defamation includes any false information that causes protests, social unrest, or psychological agony to its subject. According to AFP, the law also covers posts related to extortion and blackmail.

Chinese officials say the law will help deter smear campaigns and the spread of misinformation, though users have already expressed concern over the government's low page view and repost thresholds. Following China's recent detainment of dissident bloggers and celebrities, there are fears that today's laws may make it even easier for Beijing to curb free speech online.

 

[Windsorlou]

Severe penalties for slanderous retweets in China

Xinhua, September 9, 2013

People who post defamatory comments online in China will face up to three years in prison if their statements are widely reposted, according to a judicial interpretation issued on Monday.

The document, released by the Supreme People's Court(SPP) and the Supreme People's Procuratorate, stipulates that people will face defamation charges if online rumors they post are viewed by more than 5,000 Internet users or retweeted more than 500 times.

If those posting rumors are repeat offenders, or if their online rumors caused the victim or the victim's immediate family members to commit self-mutilation or suicide or experience mental disorders, they may also face defamation charges.

In China, people committing the crime of defamation face up to three years in prison or deprivation of political rights.

The judicial interpretation provides a legal reference for punishing online crimes such as slander, cases of which have increased in recent years, SPP spokesman Sun Jungong said on Monday.

Some Internet users fabricate rumors about others and create false information while making use of sensitive social issues, which has disrupted social order and triggered "mass incidents," Sun said, adding that the public has called for harsh punishment for such criminal activity.

The judicial interpretation, to be effective on Tuesday, is the first of its kind to regulate online rumors in China.

It metes out punishment for companies and individuals paid to delete online messages or intentionally post false information.

If a company's illegal gross revenues exceed 150,000 yuan (24,500 U.S. dollars) or its illegal gains surpass 50,000 yuan, it will face illegal business operations charges deemed "serious," according to the judicial interpretation.

The illegal gross revenue and gains amounts for individuals was set at 50,000 yuan and 20,000 yuan, respectively.

According to China's criminal law, people who engage in illegal business operations deemed "serious situations" can face up to five years in prison and fines of up to five times the amount of the illegal gains.

China's Internet communities, especially on microblog sites like Sina Weibo, have become an important channel for citizens to express views and expose corruption and abuse of power.

Sun said Internet users will continue to be encouraged to expose disciplinary and law violations.

"Even if some details of the allegations or what has been exposed are not true, as long as [Internet users] are not intentionally fabricating information to slander others...they will not be prosecuted on charges of defamation," Sun said.

Over the past month, police across China have detained a number of suspects and closed several businesses for fabricating online rumors.

A notable case has been the detention of two men in Beijing in August. Yang Xiuyu, founder of the Erma Company, and employee Qin Zhihui, were found to have created and spread online rumors, including false information about a 2011 bullet train accident and China's most famous Good Samaritan, Lei Feng.

While the crackdown on the spread of online rumors has been hailed by the government as a move to build a healthy online order, it has also prompted concerns about freedom of expression in China.

Sun believes the judicial interpretation is aimed at accurately cracking down on crimes in accordance with law, and that Internet users' rights to expression will be protected.

After the interpretation was issued, some Chinese Internet users voiced their support.

A Sina Weibo user identified as "Super Benjamin" said the judicial interpretation will stop Internet users from making irresponsible remarks.

Another user called "danchundewo2012" said a "civilized, rational Internet environment that is free of rumors is what Internet users really need."