Jurong fatal fire started from battery pack that was possibly stored improperly: State coroner
Mr Chai Chee Fong lived in a four-room flat on the fifth storey of Block 978 Jurong West Street 93 with 11 other men. PHOTO: ST FILE
Shaffiq Alkhatib
Court Correspondent
Nov 12, 2024
SINGAPORE - The state coroner has found that
a blaze in a Jurong West flat which killed a man in October 2021 originated from a battery pack that may not have been stored properly.
The pack was not on a personal mobility device (PMD) at the time of the tragedy.
In his findings into Mr Chai Chee Fong’s death, State Coroner Adam Nakhoda said that it is likely that a “thermal runaway” – or uncontrolled battery overheating – had occurred in lithium cells within the battery pack that had been placed away from the PMD.
The Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF) had engaged private certification agency TUV SUD PSB to conduct an analysis on several items recovered from the blaze, including a PMD.
The company, which was unable to determine the root cause of the thermal runaway, had stated that a mismatch between a battery pack and a charger can cause damage to such items.
The state coroner said: “A mismatch between the charger and the battery packs could have resulted in damage to the lithium cells that would eventually lead to a thermal runaway.”
The battery pack was not being charged at the time of the fire.
Mr Chai, 22, died of severe burns and smoke inhalation, and in his findings made available on Nov 12, the state coroner said that his death was due to an accident.
He added: “The discharge of heat, and ejection of hot gas and inner components caused other cells in close proximity... to similarly burn or explode.”
Hot gas or inner components were then flung towards another battery pack near the PMD, causing its lithium cells to experience thermal runaway.
He said that the battery pack farther away from the PMD had been placed under an air-conditioning unit in Mr Chai’s bedroom, adding: “It was possible that condensation, leaking or dripping of water on the battery pack had caused damage to the cells either by oxidation or corrosion.”
Investigations revealed that moisture in the cells could have caused an internal short circuit.
Mr Chai, a Malaysian, lived in a four-room flat on the fifth storey of Block 978 Jurong West Street 93 with 11 other men.
More On This Topic
Unattended cigarette caused Bedok North flat fire that killed three, including 3-year-old
Fatal Bukit Batok fire ‘likely caused by cigarette embers igniting items outside flat’
In his findings, the state coroner noted that the unit was severely overcrowded with 12 sub-tenants when there should have been only six registered ones.
One of the men, Mr Voon Ching Sun, was sleeping in the same bedroom as Mr Chai before the fire broke out.
Mr Voon woke up in the wee hours of Oct 8, 2021, when he heard Mr Chai repeatedly yelling: “There is a fire!”
He told investigators the fire in the bedroom was so big that he could not see what was ahead of him, and that he was unable to locate Mr Chai.
State Coroner Nakhoda said: “Mr Voon crawled on his hands and knees towards (the bedroom) door and could feel that he was being burnt by the fire... He unlocked the door and then made his way out of the (flat).”
Most of the men who were in the flat when the fire broke out managed to leave the unit.
However, two of them who were trapped in another bedroom due to the smoke climbed out of a window to stand on a ledge outside.
SCDF officers arrived at the scene at 2.30am, and evacuated the pair through the front door.
The fire was extinguished by about 3.05am and Mr Chai, who was found in his bedroom, was pronounced dead around 10 minutes later.
Mr Voon, who suffered severe burns and was in a state of shock, was taken to the Singapore General Hospital.
State Coroner Nakhoda said: “Unfortunately, Mr Chai, who was in close proximity to the lithium battery packs that were experiencing thermal runaway, was very badly burnt.
“Mr Voon, whose bed was further from the ignition point, was not overwhelmed by the flames as quickly, and although he suffered severe burns, he was able to escape.”
The state coroner also stressed that PMD users should be mindful of any directions manufactures give regarding the storage of such devices and external batteries.
This is to ensure that improper storage does not constitute a risk.