http://newpaper.asia1.com.sg/news/story/0,4136,199816,00.html?
We HATE S'pore
Facebook group invites S'pore-bashing and gets bashed by other netizens
By Liew Hanqing
April 24, 2009
TNP ILLUSTRATION: SIMON ANG
WITH close to 400 members, the group on social networking site Facebook can be considered popular - except that it's out to highlight all that is unpopular about Singapore.
The name of the group is blunt: Singapore Sucks!
Yes, it's a group dedicated to bashing Singapore.
The group, set up in 2007, is now being hotly discussed online after netizens posted a link to the group on several online forums and on citizen journalism website Stomp.
In a write-up on its Facebook page, the group states that its purpose is to 'raise awareness for people from everywhere in the world about the current state of Singapore and for members to vent their frustration'.
The group's profile picture, which has since been removed, was a digitally altered photograph showing several buildings in the Central Business District being hit by a 11 Sep-style terrorist attack.
Foreigners rant
Most of the members appear to be Singaporean, but there are also many foreigners who have joined the group.
A handful of these foreigners, who claim to have lived in Singapore, are active participants on discussion threads on the group's page - in particular, a thread that urges members to use the site to 'vent their frustrations about Singapore and Singaporeans'.
The first post on the thread, written by Ms Laila Allen from Australia, is a lengthy rant about her negative experiences living in Singapore.
She wrote: 'Try asking a question of your friendly sales assistant, waiter, employee, I dare you.
'You will either be met with a blank stare, or they will find someone else, who will find someone else, who will ask the manager, who brings everyone over to see what the problem is. Repeat.'
Ms Allen continued her tirade, describing Singaporeans as 'backward' and incapable of appreciating sarcasm.
She also criticised the way Singaporeans speak English.
'You are seriously over not being able to understand what the hell they are saying. No one seems to speak any one language well. Their English, often as a first language, is broken and they all have the weirdest accents,' she wrote.
Another member, Ms Jacinta Bonnici, also from Australia, detailed a series of negative experiences she had while living in Singapore.
Some of her gripes: Having people not give way to her in the MRT, and people continuing to speak Mandarin to her even after they find out she does not speak the language.
She wrote: 'We may be too brash and loud in expressing our anger, however underneath all of that anger is sadness, disbelief and hunger - hunger to be in a place where we can breathe, live and laugh again.'
Some of the harshest comments are from self-proclaimed Singaporeans.
One group member, a Mr Mark Lee who identified himself as a Singaporean, wrote: 'I concur with all the accusations levelled thus far, especially those on linguistic competency.
'Funny how you travel half the world around (sic) and are still able to identify Sinkies once they open their mouths.'
Some netizens, however, were quick to rebut some of the more harshly worded comments on the discussion thread.
Mr Justin Chai wrote: 'We are quiet when you (foreigners) complain that something is not to your ideals, liking or similar to the treatment in your home country where you are the majority.
'But to openly bash our community: Are we supposed to stand quietly in the sidelines and let you vandalise our name?'
Another netizen, Mr Kwa Jie Hao, wrote: 'There are certainly many facets of Singapore that are detestable, but for every rude and socially inept Singaporean that you have had the misfortune to meet, there is an open-minded (and generally younger) Singaporean who does not make the same mistakes...
'As such, I wish you good fortune in avoiding the unpleasant occurrences that, lamentably, surface in our beautiful city from time to time.'
One netizen, posting on the Sgclub forum, added: 'It's the silly ppl (sic) degrading themselves and everyone else with them at work again.
'I don't understand why some people like to whine at every little bad thing in life rather than doing something constructive about it.'
People behind the group
So who's behind this Singapore-bashing group?
The Facebook page says the creator is one Mr Wils Cheng .
When The New Paper e-mailed to ask him why he set up the group, he simply referred us to the write-up on the group's Facebook page.
He would not say if he is Singaporean.
On whether he felt his group's stand was too harsh, Mr Cheng replied: 'I do regret that the name of the group may be 'harsh and unfair', but the things we advocate - free speech, free blogging, less restriction on art and expression, and cultural progress - are all positive.'
We contacted two other members from the group, but both did not respond by press time.
One, a Mr Thomas Frederick Lim, was later found to be no longer an officer of the group.
He was also no longer listed as a group member when The New Paper checked the group's member list a day after we contacted him.
Responding to online criticism about his group, Mr Cheng said: 'Only a fascist and/or a defender of fascism would be offended by these positive points.'