If just 1000 of the 10k kena conned by the Papaya cronies have the guts to fight for their rights, the Papayas would be scared shitting and peeing in their pants.
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=acAgoLqESQAU&refer=home
Lehman Bond Losers Protest in Hong Kong, Seek Refund (Update1)
By Wendy Leung and Theresa Tang
Oct. 14 (Bloomberg) -- Nicole Chan says her mother's savings were in Hong Kong investments linked to Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., and she's too scared to tell her.
``I can't sleep,'' said Chan, a 30-year-old shipping clerk. About HK$500,000 ($64,367) was invested in the products via Citic Ka Wah Bank Ltd. ``I am facing a lot of pressures. I don't know how to explain it to her.''
Hundreds of Hong Kong investors protested in the streets last week, chanted at the city's parliament and crowded outside banks, demanding compensation. Chan's predicament illustrates how ripples of Lehman's collapse are spreading around the world, causing losses for investors and challenging governments to review regulations.
Thousands of Hong Kong individuals bought the so-called minibonds: investments guaranteed by Lehman and linked to the debt of the biggest Hong Kong companies including
Hutchison Whampoa Ltd. and Sun Hung Kai Properties Ltd.
Minibonds was the brand name for one series of products, designed for individuals. As little as $5,000 had to be invested in the bonds, prospectuses show, compared with $100,000 for most bonds sold to institutional investors.
Matthew Russell, spokesman for Lehman in Hong Kong, declined to comment, referring only to a regulator
press release.
Some of the bonds, arranged by Lehman and sold through local banks, have defaulted. It's unclear how much, if anything, investors will get back. New York-based Lehman, once the fourth- largest U.S. securities firm, filed for bankruptcy protection Sept. 15. Assets were frozen by the proceedings.
`Disaster'
``It's a disaster,'' Peter Chan, coordinator of the Lehman minibond investors, who formed a protest group, said outside Hong Kong's Legislative Council. Chan said his wife invested HK$470,000 in bonds at
Bank of China Ltd.
Bank of China said Oct. 7 it set up a special inquiries unit and vowed help on individual cases. It also was studying a Hong Kong government proposal to ask banks to buy back some of the bonds.
Regulators set up hotlines to handle complaints and Hong Kong authorities formed a task force and pledged a ``systemic review'' of regulations.
Hong Kong's
Securities and Futures Commission said individual investors in the city had HK$15.6 billion of structured notes arranged by or linked to Lehman, including HK$12.57 billion of the minibonds.
Missed Payments
The bonds, which offered better returns than deposits, were sold in Hong Kong and Singapore. Lehman missed interest payments on some of the minibonds, the Monetary Authority of Singapore said Oct. 7.
Some minibonds issued in the last two years had maturities of three to seven years and annual fixed returns of between 5 percent and 8 percent. Hong Kong deposits currently earn as little as 0.01 percent.
The minibonds were secured by collateralized debt obligations, a type of structured security backed by debt. The bonds arranged by Lehman were linked to corporate debt, according to sale documents on the regulator's Web Site.
There are more than 40,000 minibond investors, Chan said. He said investors may get about 50 cents on the dollar under the plan.
``More than half of the victims are aged over 50,'' he said. ``They're almost losing what they've earned their whole life. The government should press the banks to take up more responsibilities. We want our money back.''
Task Force
Singapore will review marketing practices after complaints by customers they were misled into buying Lehman-linked products. It may impose fines and admonish banks, though won't ask them to compensate investors, Singapore's regulator said.
The Hong Kong Monetary Authority has received 7,730 complaints, and plans to investigate nine banks selling the bonds.
Legislators criticized HKMA, the city's de facto central bank, as well as the SFC in parliament yesterday for failing to monitor financial institutions selling the bonds, according to local media.
Joseph Yam, HKMA chief, was described by legislator Raymond Wong as having failed in his duty, the
Standard reported today. Yam promised to announce the result of the first investigation this week, the paper reported.
Financial Secretary
John Tsang met with officials of banks who acted as distributors, brokers and trustees for Lehman. Twenty-one banks and three brokers sold investors minibonds and related derivatives issued or guaranteed by Lehman. Tsang proposed the buyback plan Oct. 7.
``The teller never mentioned Lehman's name and the risks that I might lose every cent,'' said a 57-year-old retired woman identifying herself by her surname, Wong. ``It's my mother's money. She's handicapped and old, I just want to get a better return for her.''
Legal Action
Wong, in tears outside parliament, said she invested HK$500,000 in notes guaranteed by Lehman at Citic Ka Wah.
The bank has been working with affected customers to update them and address concerns, and is cooperating with regulators, Citic Ka Wah spokeswoman Kwok Pui King said.
Hong Kong investors are considering taking legal action against Lehman, and may seek help from the
Consumer Council, which has a fund that can support lawsuits,
Albert Ho, Hong Kong's Democratic Party Chairman, said Sept. 23.
Hong Kong rules on structured products may also be overhauled after a three-month review.
Creditors of Hong Kong companies received compensation in the past. Clients of failed brokerage C.A. Pacific Securities got back as much as HK$600 million from the stock exchange and the SFC in 1998. Creditors of Peregrine Investments Holdings Ltd., which collapsed in 1998, recovered HK$4.9 billion.
``I previously thought the bank is somewhere you can trust to put your money,'' said Chan, the shipping clerk. ``I have been asking the bank about my mother's money, they only keep replying to me `we will assist you as much as we can' without telling me if the money is all gone.''
To contact the reporter for this story: Theresa Tang in Hong Kong at
[email protected]; Wendy Leung in Hong Kong at
[email protected]
Last Updated: October 13, 2008 22:16 EDT