http://www.tremeritus.com/2013/10/13/govt-must-impose-tough-penalties-against-la-fondue/
[h=2]
Govt must impose tough penalties against La Fondue[/h]
October 13th, 2013 |
Author:
Contributions
On Friday, 11 October 2013, unemployment support group
Transitionings.Org leader Gilbert Goh announced that he had called for a
nationwide boycott of Swiss restaurant La Fondue located at Dempsey Hill, due to
its discriminatory recruitment practices. The reason stated for the boycott was
because the restaurant had placed an ad for a chef where it was stated that the
restaurant was “currently an all-Filipino working environment” and that the job
vacancy was “only for Filipinos”.
The saga began when a sharp-eyed netizen had spotted the ad and linked it to
Acting Manpower Minister Tan Chuan Jin’s Facebook wall. While the ad did not
name the restaurant, it did give its address as “25 Dempsey Road”. Another
netizen checked out the address and found that the only restaurant that fit the
description was La Fondue. A third netizen then delivered a warning to the
restaurant via its Facebook page that he would be calling for a boycott of the
establishment for its discriminatory hiring practices. While the company’s
Facebook administrator deleted his warning soon after, by then it had already
caught the attention of Mr. Goh who announced that Transitionings.Org would be
organizing an indefinite nation-wide boycott against the restaurant in protest
against the ad. He also sent an email to TAFEP and Mr Tan notifying them of the
restaurant’s discriminatory recruitment ad.
On the morning of Saturday, 12 October 2013, Mr. Ravinder Pal, the CEO of the
restaurant issued an apology for the ad. In his statement, he said that a staff
member who “was not authorized to issue recruitment ads” and who was “acting on
his own” issued the ad “without the knowledge or consent of the company”. He
added that the company’s recruitment policies were carried out “in accordance
with the country’s laws” and said that the particular staff member “would be
severely dealt with”.
However, the same sharp-eyed netizen who originally spotted and reported the
offending ad had done some digging around and discovered that the restaurant had
previously issued an ad for a restaurant manager that stated that the post was
“only for female Filipinos”. The same person, a Mr. Roginald Santos Oloresisimo,
who was originally from the Filipino province of Taguig, had issued both ads.
Because of Mr Pal’s highly unconvincing explanation, Mr. Goh announced that he
had written in for further clarification and that the boycott would continue
until further notice.
A closer look at Mr. Pal’s apology and explanation would immediately raise
several questions. While the announcement did not name Mr. Oloresisimo, it did
confirm that he was a member of their staff, which raises the question: what is
his position there then? If he was “was not authorized to issue recruitment ads”
and was “acting on his own” as declared, then why did he issued at least two
separate recruitment ads, one for the chef and one for the restaurant manager?
If he had really issued the ads “without the knowledge or consent of the
company” as declared, then who is paying the salaries of the staff he recruited?
Surely at least both the company’s HR and General Managers must be aware of this
since both their signatures will be required to issue the new staffs’ paychecks.
And if the Payroll Department is separate from the HR Department as practiced by
some companies, then at least 3 separate managers must be aware of this wouldn’t
it? Whatever the case may be, it also raises serious questions over how Mr Pal
himself is managing the company since the obvious inference that one would draw
from it is that he is entirely clueless about what his management team has been
doing all this while. So one is forced to conclude that he is either incompetent
whose management team had been jerking him around without his knowledge or that
his explanation is untrue.
Whatever the truth about the management of La Fondue really is, there is no
denying that this case is a true test for MoM and its agency TAFEP, the
government’s much vaunted tripartism policy is dealing with labor relations and
even its immigration and social integration policies. If La Fondue truly has
been recruiting only Filipinos as the two ads in question proudly declare, then
it is very clear that the management has been practicing xenophobic racial
discrimination against non-Filipinos. Obviously this also means that they seek
only to commune with their own kind and have absolutely no desire to integrate
with locals.
In view of the government’s continuous exhortation for locals to integrate
with the immigrants, itself a farcical idea since it is the foreigners who
should integrate with the locals and their continuous criticisms of anybody who
objects to the perceived favorable treatment for them as xenophobic, failure to
come down hard on La Fondue would be seen as the government caving in to
xenophobic racist foreigners. It would also demonstrate to the people that TAFEP
and MoM are entirely toothless and that the government itself is not serious or
may even be entirely helpless about dealing with errant employers who
discriminate against locals, which would be a clear-cut failure of tripartism.
If the government fails to impose tough penalties against La Fondue, then the
people’s fast crumbling trust in the government will only be further eroded.
Maybe eroded badly enough for PM Lee to have his wish to retire from public
office before the age of 70 come true in 2016…
Darth Vader
VN:R_U [1.9.22_1171]