Tanjong Pagar car crash victims’ families settle out of court with driver’s estate
SCDF personnel working at the site of the car crash in Tanjong Pagar on Feb 13, 2021. PHOTO: ST FILE
Joyce Lim
Senior Correspondent
AUG 1, 2023
SINGAPORE – The families of three men who died in a car crash in Tanjong Pagar in 2021 have reached an out-of-court settlement with the estate of the driver, Mr Jonathan Long Junwei.
The details of the settlement, however, remain confidential.
The families of Mr Eugene Yap Zheng Min, 29, Mr Teo Qi Xiang, 26, and Mr Gary Wong Hong Chieh, 29,
had sought to claim a total of about $1.7 million from Mr Long’s estate.
The family of the fourth passenger, Mr Elvin Tan Yong Hao, 28, had initiated a claim of about $477,000, but there has been no legal proceeding to date.
Mr Long, 29, was the last person behind the wheel of a white BMW M4 that crashed into a shophouse before it burst into flames,
killing all five men in the car.
The State Coroner ruled the five deaths a traffic-related misadventure.
The Straits Times had previously reported that the families had filed their claims with the Singapore courts in November 2022. The three claimants were represented by Mr Goh Choon Wah of Characterist.
Mr Long’s mother, Madam Chan Ngerng Pheng, 58, who is the administrator of his estate, is represented by Mr Nigel Bogaars of Bogaars & Din.
The mediation sessions were held separately and mediated by retired district judge David Lim.
Madam Chan told ST: “The mediations were emotionally challenging, but we’re grateful to our lawyer, who relentlessly pursued peaceful and amicable settlements in a professional manner, and was an invaluable ally throughout this journey.
“He worked tirelessly alongside the families and the mediator to achieve a fair and acceptable resolution for all parties involved.”
Madam Chan added that she is grateful that the families are able to move forward and embark on the process of healing following the settlement.
“We hope that the public will allow all affected parties the space to move forward from this tragedy and to honour the memory of our loved ones,” she said.
The families of the three claimants could not be reached for comment.
The accident,
which took place at about 5.40am on Feb 13, 2021, had shocked Singapore, prompting renewed discussions about road safety and the dangers of driving under the influence of alcohol.
The vehicle insurer, AXA Singapore, had repudiated liability under the policy for any claims arising from the accident after a coroner’s inquiry showed Mr Long had been driving under the influence of alcohol.
The inquiry revealed that Mr Long had a blood alcohol reading of 86mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood. This exceeded the legal limit of 80mg per 100ml.
The coroner’s inquiry also showed that the group of friends had taken turns to drive Mr Long’s newly bought BMW around the Tanjong Pagar area.
They had gone to a friend’s home to celebrate Chinese New Year before proceeding to a Korean restaurant in Tanjong Pagar. All of them had drunk alcohol.
At around 5am, the group left the restaurant to see off one of the friends, who was catching a taxi home.
While they were outside the restaurant, Mr Yap asked Mr Long to let him and another friend, Ms Phoo Yi Lin, test-drive his new sports car.
Mr Yap, who was the first to take the car for a ride early that morning, was later found to have a blood alcohol reading of 119mg of alcohol per 100ml of blood.
He was joined by two friends, Mr Park Se Jin and Ms Phoo, who also took turns at the wheel.
Mr Long was the fourth driver.
Mr Yap, Mr Teo (whose blood alcohol reading was 162mg), Mr Tan (128mg) and Mr Wong (111mg) joined him in the car even though the vehicle had designated seats for the driver and only three passengers.
Mr Long, who had
clocked speeds of up to 182kmh while he was driving the BMW in the area before the crash, was speeding along Tanjong Pagar Road when the car skidded and mounted a kerb.
It struck a pillar at an estimated speed of between 87kmh and 99kmh and burst into flames.
Mr Long’s fiancee – Ms Raybe Oh Siew Huey, then 26 –
suffered severe burns when she tried to rescue the people in the car.
In their statement of claims filed in November 2022, relatives of Mr Yap, Mr Teo and Mr Wong accused Mr Long of driving “in such a way that he lost control” of the car before the accident.
They alleged that the crash was caused solely, or contributed, by the negligence of Mr Long.
Madam Chan had denied all allegations and claims.
She said in her defence filed that the deaths of the claimants were contributed by their own negligence in travelling as passengers in the car driven by her son, when they knew or ought to have known that her son had been drinking alcohol in such quantities and to such an extent as to render him unfit to drive the car carefully or safely.