• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Is a one-party state good for Singapore?

ozeman

Alfrescian
Loyal
Like it or not the Singapore of today is a one-party state.

The PAP government claims that they know what is best for all Singaporeans. That Singapore does not need a robust opposition to ensure checks and balances are kept for good goverance.

The PAP further claims that Singapore cannot survive without it. Will there be riots and chaos if more opposition members are voted into parliament?

Lets discuss.
 

fivestars

Alfrescian
Loyal
PAP win election in 1968 is because:-

1) Win new Indian Devan Nair votes
2) Win new Chinese Goh Keng Swee Votes
3) Win new Singapore UMNO Jump Ship Votes
4) Southern Vietnam war remind Barisan Socilist member to support PAP to prevent religion exˈtremist and racial communist from the north Singapore.
5) PRC had been control by Communist, no way for Chinese to back to Mainland China. They need to defend Singapore.

Singapore very first GE for Parliament saw the longest campaigning period ever in Singapore history but also the shortest time Parliament was convened after a GE. Following the resignations of 11 BS Members of Parliament and exodus of two BS MPs from Singapore to escape the Internal Security Department, the legislature was left with only PAP MPs. BS boycotted the GE on the grounds that Singapore's independence was "phoney" and several opposition parties heeded its call.

The chiefs of PKMS (former UMNO), Ahmad Haji Taff, and SCP (former MCA), Chng Boon Eng, turned up but did not file their nominations. Due to this, three precedents were set - the least number of seats contested in a GE, the first time PAP was returned to power on nomination day and the first time it won all seats to return a pure one-party legislature. Henceforth, walkovers became a perpetual feature in every succeeding GE.

1st Parliament dissolution: 8 February 1968 [Thu]
Nomination day: 17 February 1968 [Sat]
Polling day: 13 April 1968 [Sat]
2nd Parliament convention: 6 May 1968 [Mon]

Eligible voters: 759,367
Voters in walkover constituencies: 674,484 (88.8%)
Total voters: 84,883 (11.2%)
Total voter turnout: 77,952 (91.8%)

2012 - 1968 = 44 years ago. plus 21 years old. The youngest voter age is 65 years old.

In 2012, people who below 65 years are new voter who never fear with North Communist are 90% votes.

Can PAP still win. Unless they attack Malaysia to create tension.
 

wrcboi

Alfrescian
Loyal
is a one shopping mall, 1 supermarket, 1 food store, 1 cell phone operator, 1 bank and etc... good for you???

it only represents monopoly and controlled prices where and the possiblity of bad service....

anything without any competition is no good....people dont get threaten to work hard
 

fivestars

Alfrescian
Loyal
If UMNO Malaysia unable to leader Barisan National. PAP no longer important for non Muslim Singapore.

If PAS and PKR can handle Malaysia Federal Union Affair fairly and give freedom to all member states, PAP one party system no longer a myths but out dated system.
 

wrcboi

Alfrescian
Loyal
If UMNO Malaysia unable to leader Barisan National. PAP no longer important for non Muslim Singapore.

If PAS and PKR can handle Malaysia Federal Union Affair fairly and give freedom to all member states, PAP one party system no longer a myths but out dated system.

its already an out dated system...just take a look at taiwan, japan, korea
 
G

General Veers

Guest
You want it to be a communist state like China and North Korea?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

fivestars

Alfrescian
Loyal
During 1968, the first, second and third generation new comer or sinkek, worry UMNO Malaysia cut the male/female one part be a muslim and force them become baba who speak malay and english.

Political change on one party system is very hard. We wish new generation that under stand malay muslim and the independent of Singapore with strong NS Chinese Race army will vote for opposition like RP and SDP.
 

ozeman

Alfrescian
Loyal
That's what I don't understand about Singaporeans! How could they allow a monopoly to survive for 50 years!

Monopoly is never good.

Monopoly breeds contempt, is expensive to run and totally inefficient.




is a one shopping mall, 1 supermarket, 1 food store, 1 cell phone operator, 1 bank and etc... good for you???

it only represents monopoly and controlled prices where and the possiblity of bad service....

anything without any competition is no good....people dont get threaten to work hard
 

ozeman

Alfrescian
Loyal
Lets look at the world around us. Which one party state has been good for its people in the long run?

North Korea, Albania, China?




If UMNO Malaysia unable to leader Barisan National. PAP no longer important for non Muslim Singapore.

If PAS and PKR can handle Malaysia Federal Union Affair fairly and give freedom to all member states, PAP one party system no longer a myths but out dated system.
 

ozeman

Alfrescian
Loyal
The opposition is only able to win a few token seats because it is an unlevel playing field.

It is hard to contest against the PAP when the goal posts keep on changing with gerrymandering, GRCs, high deposits to contest, etc.

Good opposition members are jailed, sued to bankruptcy or run out of town!


During 2006, all contested GRC and SMC. Only Potong Pasir BN(SDA) and Hougang BS(WP), opposition win.

This is the fact
 

fivestars

Alfrescian
Loyal
Lets look at the world around us. Which one party state has been good for its people in the long run?

North Korea, Albania, China?

The problem in 1969 many Chinese Malaysian die due to not understand Tanah Melayu or Malayan or Land of Malay Muslim that They are Malay nation, they have Malay King and they are new citizen.
 

fivestars

Alfrescian
Loyal
The opposition is only able to win a few token seats because it is an unlevel playing field.

It is hard to contest against the PAP when the goal posts keep on changing with gerrymandering, GRCs, high deposits to contest, etc.

Good opposition members are jailed, sued to bankruptcy or run out of town!

Control high post vacancy, control very professional vacancy, increase minimum election cost, increase GRC racial tension between Chinese, Malay, Indian and others and others control is learnt from White KMT Chiang Kai Sek.
 

ozeman

Alfrescian
Loyal
when i was a kid, i felt totally singaporean. i was never afraid of the malays and indians. they were my fellow countrymen!

this is another fear propagated by the PAP to keep the population under its control.


During 1968, the first, second and third generation new comer or sinkek, worry UMNO Malaysia cut the male/female one part be a muslim and force them become baba who speak malay and english.

Political change on one party system is very hard. We wish new generation that under stand malay muslim and the independent of Singapore with strong NS Chinese Race army will vote for opposition like RP and SDP.
 

ozeman

Alfrescian
Loyal
even with his cambridge education, lky is a chinaman afer all! heh heh.......



Control high post vacancy, control very professional vacancy, increase minimum election cost, increase GRC racial tension between Chinese, Malay, Indian and others and others control is learnt from White KMT Chiang Kai Sek.
 
Top