The Prophet Said This 1500 Years Ago, and Science Recently Verified It

[duluxe]

It's an open book religion. It's all in the scriptures, Quran and the Hadiths.
Prove us wrong.


Nope. What is said by the prophet is in the Hadiths.
Only Allah's words are in the Quran.
Anyway it's futile for an islamophobes like you.
But since I've done the job, ie, pass on the message, good luck to you.
You cannot claim the message did come to you on judgement day.

According to @syed putra , hadiths only appeared a few centuries later after the death of muhammed, they are unreliable hearsays and a lot of after injections.
According to @JohnTan , the Quran is thinner than the bible and so not comprehensive enough. So, hadiths were added later.

Koran, muslims claim hafiz were the witnesses. Hadiths, who were the witnesses?

 

[Loofydralb]

According to @syed putra , hadiths only appeared a few centuries later after the death of muhammed, they are unreliable hearsays and a lot of after injections.
According to @JohnTan , the Quran is thinner than the bible and so not comprehensive enough. So, hadiths were added later.

Koran, muslims claim hafiz were the witnesses. Hadiths, who were the witnesses?

Hadiths are in oral tradition until they compiled it about 100+ years later into volumes.

And witnesses to what the prophet did or said we're not necessarily Hafiz.

Well, enough of answering disbelieving KAAFIR.

 

[duluxe]

xx: "The idea that the human body has 360 joints is a concept from the ancient Indian medical text Charaka Samhita. The book was written by the famous physician Maharshi Charaka around 2,000 years ago."


https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8514395/
https://www.quora.com/Who-said-there-are-360-human-joints-first-Charaka-Samhita-or-Prophet-Muhammed
https://www.quora.com/Who-said-there-are-360-human-joints-first-Charaka-Samhita-or-Prophet-Muhammed

 

[Loofydralb]

Many missed the point of the post.

How did the prophet knew? He couldn't read nor write. No books, schools or universities and hospitals.
Did he study the human body, dissect and investigate. No. Islam forbid mutilation of the human body after death.
The prophet never claimed he was the first to know. This fact has been true since Adam. Anyone with half a brain can cut up a body and find out.
How did the prophet know? All that in the middle of desert. That's the miracle!

 

[syed putra]

Accuracy is paramount.
According to Dong Zhongshu, humans have 366 small joints, which is similar to the number of days in a year. A big error in science and medicine.
Also books from china in the Arab peninsula? And read by an illiterate?
Right....

Big question mark on illiteracy. It was used to justify why the Quran was not written by mahomet. But by scribes.
There is no need for a holy book.

 

[Loofydralb]

Big question mark on illiteracy. It was used to justify why the Quran was not written by mahomet. But by scribes.
There is no need for a holy book.

If there wasn't the revelation, you'd be no different from a hindu

 

[duluxe]

Big question mark on illiteracy. It was used to justify why the Quran was not written by mahomet. But by scribes.
There is no need for a holy book.

You hit the nail on the camel's ass. Claiming illiteracy has much implications behind. As they could claim the Prophet did not copy from existing religions nearby. And they could provide excuse why the koran was not written down immediately and so on.

During the time of the Prophet, the arab tribe did not have its own writing scribe yet. But that begs another good question for us to think about! Since the koran was such an important relevation from the devine, why was the koran not recorded down immediately by borrowing writings from nearby cultures? The persians has a writing system called "Pahlavi" and they could use greek writing or aramaic.

Before the time the koran was written down in arabic, the arab already has an established culture of hafiz to so called transmit the words of the koran verbally. Why the words of muhammed was not passed down as well by hafiz? His words are not that important? We know today his sayings are almost as important as the Quran.

Why the hadiths was not compiled at the same time as the Quran or soon after the Quran was written down?

 

[duluxe]