• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Sound sales

metalslug

Alfrescian
Loyal
http://tnp.sg/news/story/0,4136,208656,00.html?

SOUND SALES
This shop's sales pitch comes with 'chorus'
July 25, 2009

NP_IMAGES_PSOLD.jpg

SALES SESSIONS: (Above) Matakiteya salesgirl and customers. (Below) A woman (in green-blue shirt) talks to our reporter (left), while a middle-aged woman gets her 'special pass' stamped. TNP PICTURES: KELVIN CHNG

THEY sell everything from detergents to pillows.

These sales people move between estates every three months or so, targeting retirees who are lured by gifts.

The sales pitch is conducted behind locked doors with windows covered up with posters.

Inside, middle-aged men and women roar in unison when the salesman makes his pitch.

Holding up a waist-belt, he yells in Hokkien: 'Do you want this?' 'Yes!' the crowd cries.

The items are not cheap - $120 for a pillow and $200 for a pain-relief waist-belt.

The people behind the event say they don't apply pressure tactics. Case says they've received feedback from two people, but no official complaints.

The sales people are not making medical claims so the Health Sciences Authority (HSA) says they don't need to be licensed.

And the people attending the event don't seem to mind forking out the money. Like Mary (not her real name), a retiree in her 80s.

NP_IMAGES_PSOLD-C9P.jpg


Her daily routine includes watching her afternoon soap opera on TV and visits to the shop, Matakiteya, which sells a variety of what are largely health products.

Mary gets there by 8am every day, half an hour before the doors open, because she has to hustle with other retirees and elderly folk - some in wheelchairs, some with walking frames - to get into the long queue.

The shop has only three sales sessions daily; each seats about 80 and consists of a two-hour presentation of the featured product for the day.

Customers enter after getting their special passes stamped at the door.

Matakiteya, which means 'Come again' in Japanese, moved to Block 727, Clementi West Street 2, about two weeks ago. It is the only shop of its kind in Singapore, changing venues every three months, and with branches in Japan, Malaysia, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Indonesia and Cambodia.

Mary, and many like her, have followed the shop for years as it moves from estate to estate, drawn by incentives such as free rolls of toilet paper.

Freebies

The freebies given out every session include product samples, Chinese cooking wine and cans of longans.

Mary told The New Paper in Mandarin: 'Old people like me, we have nothing to do anyway.'

Mary lives with her daughter, Angie, 45, who is unemployed. Together they spend over $1,000 a year on Matakiteya's products.

These include a $120 pillow, a $200 pain-relief waist-belt, and $600 on pills said to cleanse the body of food colourings and preservatives.

She gets about $500 a month from renting out a room in her three-bedroom flat and from her four sons.

Matakiteya's goods range from a $4 bath soap to a $2,000 mattress that contains a crystal silicate mineral called tourmaline. According to the company website, tourmaline has been proven to improve circulation, relieve stress and ease fatigue.

During each session, shop manager Mr Lawrence Ong explains the uses of the products in both Hokkien and Mandarin.

The sales pitches are noisy sessions, peppered with jokes and cheers. A trio of salesgirls chorus 'Hai!' or 'Tio' after each sentence ('Yes' in Japanese and Hokkien respectively).

Every time the main speaker demanded: 'Do you understand what we are saying?', or 'Do you want this product?', everyone would respond in unison: 'Yes!'

The New Paper was treated to a short lecture on the alleged healing power of infra-red rays and touramaline when we sat in last week.

But these claims have not been verified by any authority. Nor are there any laws that regulate health supplements. (See sidebar.)

A passer-by, a Malaysian chef who wanted to be known only as Mr Heng, said: 'It sounds like they're playing games inside but you can't see anything because the shop front is opaque.'

Sales promotion gig

When told that it was a sales promotion gig, the puzzled 42-year-old asked: 'Why must they close the door? No one knows what they're selling and some people might not dare to go in.'

Is Matakiteya pressuring customers into buying expensive products?

Said Mr Ong: 'People have their own minds. We can't force them to buy anything.'

But the shop manager, who has worked for the company for nine years, admitted that the only thing he knew about the products he was selling was that they were 'all from Japan'.

The rapid-fire questions and chorus of 'Hai!' or 'Tio', he added, were to 'create an atmosphere', and not to persuade the customers into purchasing.

So why cover the shopfront with posters, and lock the doors? These measures, replied Mr Ong, were to help customers focus on the sales presentation.

When questioned if his business is targeting the old and the gullible, the shop manager replied: 'I can't stop what other people think about us - it's up to people to decide if we have anything to hide.'

Said Ms Angela Tan, one of Matakiteya's business partners: 'We've been around for 11 years already. If there's anything fishy about us, surely the news would have got out by now.'

Han Yongming and Hoe Pei Shan
 

metalslug

Alfrescian
Loyal
http://tnp.sg/news/story/0,4136,208654,00.html?

'Authorities can't regulate everything'
July 25, 2009




BE CAREFUL when you pop that pill, because there are no laws regulating health supplements in Singapore.

Lawyer Mr Tan Hee Joek of Tan See Swan & Co, said this may be a legal 'loophole', especially considering the hardsell methods employed by some advertisers of such products that target the elderly.

'Authorities can't regulate everything, and policymakers appear to have chosen to draw a fine line between products that claim to 'cure', and those that don't,' explained Mr Tan.


Only health supplements that make a claim to cure certain diseases fall under the purview of the Health Sciences Authorities (HSA) as offences in advertising and sales promotion.

According to HSA, health supplements are not subjected to pre-market reviews for safety, quality and effectiveness before they are marketed.

But there is 'post-marketing surveillance' by HSA, which include random sampling of products for screening of harmful contaminants.

Matakiteya

A HSA spokesman confirmed that Matakiteya's advertising and sales promotion are 'not licensed' by HSA, and its products are not HSA-approved, because they are not medicine.

The only ones responsible for the safety of health supplements are those who import and sell it, added the spokesman.

A check with the Consumers Association of Singapore (Case) revealed that two people had given negative feedback about Matakiteya and the company it is under, Akatsuki Pte Ltd.

But Case's executive director, Mr Seah Seng Choon, told The New Paper that because these comments were submitted to Case as feedback, and not formal complaints, Case could not take up the matter.

A formal complaint involves a fee paid to Case and requires registration if the consumer wishes Case to follow up.

One consumer commented that the vendor had been marketing their products to housewives and homemakers in the form of free gifts.

When The New Paper made trips down to Matakiteya last week, we were given free plaster-sized sample strips that are supposed to help relief pain.

When asked how much they were, shop manager Mr Lawrence Ong replied that he could not tell us, and that they were 'too expensive to sell.'

What we were invited to purchase, however, were waist belts infused with the same crystal silicate, tourmaline, that other customers had bought at $220.

When asked why Matakiteya used the sample strips to promote a different product, Mr Ong replied: 'They have the same ingredients, so they are the same thing.'

Dispute

The other dispute reviewed by Case involved a consumer who had bought health products from Akatsuki, at $796.

There had been a one-for-one promotion and the consumer had purchased two bottles of the product, claiming that the staff had told him that it could cure his knee problem and would be beneficial for his eyes.

But after finishing a bottle, the consumer found there was no significant results, and had told Case that he had been misled by the staff and wanted a refund of $398.

Case told The New Paper that, until formal complaints are received, it will 'monitor the situation'.

Should health supplements be more stringently regulated, with laws put in place then?

Mr Tan said it is not a simple issue.

This is largely because of the difficulties in defining exactly what the subjective term 'hardselling' is, and what should be regulated in relation to health supplements.

Han Yongming and Hoe Pei Shan
 
Top