Silat Vs Wing Chun

[Balls2U]

 

[syed putra]

The silat guy "stance or kuda kuda" is all wrong. Silat stance should be for stability.this guy like kung fu stance.

 

[countryman]

Can silat be made into movie like Ip Man wing chun?

 

[Rogue Trader]

Can silat be made into movie like Ip Man wing chun?

Haven't you watched Raid Redemption 1 and 2?

 

[syed putra]

Can silat be made into movie like Ip Man wing chun?

No as its movement are not exciting to watch. Unless its for wedding where they do a sort of a silat dance.

 

[A Singaporean]

Silat is a joke. Just like saying yoga is a martial art.

 

[sweetiepie]

My uncle KNN whether is silat or wing chun or karate or mma the only leeference lies in the pose before fight started or during resting interval KNN during actual fight all is same else cannot pair up at all KNN

 

[laksaboy]

MMA = Muay Thai + BJJ. Every other martial arts is impractical. You can learn for fun, but don't expect to seriously compete in MMA fights with them.

 

[sweetiepie]

MMA = Muay Thai + BJJ. Every other martial arts is impractical. You can learn for fun, but don't expect to seriously compete in MMA fights with them.

KNN if the fighter insist to apply their arts the leesult will be kana beaten jialat KNN endup they also will need to use mma to fight back mma KNN

 

[sweetiepie]

KNN if the fighter insist to apply their arts the leesult will be kana beaten jialat KNN endup they also will need to use mma to fight back mma KNN

My uncle can give a real street ah being fight as example KNN eg last time my uncles classmate is trained in taekwondo when he fight with another classmate all he can do is high kick kick kick spinning kick etc KNN if my uncle is the opponent he won't be so stoopid to stand there and let him have the advantage KNN my uncle will quickly lie down and use the wriggling worm kick his lampar KNN how he going to apply what he is trained ? KNN

 

[Leckmichamarsch]

The silat guy "stance or kuda kuda" is all wrong. Silat stance should be for stability.this guy like kung fu stance.

CAMEL STANCE
SILAT IS SHIT POOtra

 

[Rogue Trader]

Silat is useless without practicing the traditional Malay magic

 

[laksaboy]

Silat is useless without practicing the traditional Malay magic

They need to wield this to have their manhood intact.

 

[glockman]

Please do not fight. Practice love and peace. Shalom.

 

[Balls2U]

No as its movement are not exciting to watch. Unless its for wedding where they do a sort of a silat dance.

Muay Thai also has it's own ritualistic dance.

 

[Balls2U]

MMA = Muay Thai + BJJ. Every other martial arts is impractical. You can learn for fun, but don't expect to seriously compete in MMA fights with them.

I disagree. Ask a MMA chap to put his skills against a Shaolin monk or a Baji Quan expert and see what happens.

 

[JohnTan]

I disagree. Ask a MMA chap to put his skills against a Shaolin monk or a Baji Quan expert and see what happens.

I've never seen this sort of asiatic marital arts crap work in fights before, be it a street brawl or match. The demos all have the same theme where the attacker throws a direct punch and stands still, giving the defender time to react and counterattack.

Stick to boxing. Boxers punch hard and fast, and they are constantly on the move. This sort of asiatic crap doesn't work in a boxing match or mma match.

 

[A Singaporean]

Silat is useless without practicing the traditional Malay magic

Yes.

 

[Balls2U]

I've never seen this sort of asiatic marital arts crap work in fights before, be it a street brawl or match. The demos all have the same theme where the attacker throws a direct punch and stands still, giving the defender time to react and counterattack.

Stick to boxing. Boxers punch hard and fast, and they are constantly on the move. This sort of asiatic crap doesn't work in a boxing match or mma match.

That's because most of the practitioners are charlatans. You haven't seen the real deal yet. The specky guy in yellow in the video is not to be messed around with. If I am not wrong, his master was the chief bodyguard of the former Taiwanese President.

 

[syed putra]

Silat is useless without practicing the traditional Malay magic

Nope