#1
The PAP often get the Straits Times pawns to cite "experts" to soften the ground and justify some impending policies to the citizens
Experts see scope for taking away road space from cars to make way for buses, cyclists or pedestrians downtown
A cycling path being built outside Covenant Evangelical Free Church in Jelapang Road. In heartland areas, the authorities have taken away road space for cycling paths in certain places, for instance, at a 100m stretch along Jelapang Road in Bukit Panjang. ST PHOTO: NG SOR LUAN
They share views on MOT plans to reimagine road infrastructure amid Covid-19 travel shifts
Toh Ting Wei
Singapore's downtown is an area where the authorities could take away road space from cars to make way for public buses, cyclists or pedestrians, said transport experts.
Doing so would bring about multiple benefits, such as revitalising street-level retail and making public transport smoother and more attractive, they added.
They were giving their take on plans by the Ministry of Transport (MOT) to make use of the opportunity provided by the Covid-19 pandemic to reimagine road infrastructure here. Transport Minister Ong Ye Kung said the pandemic has reduced traffic and led to new travel patterns, giving rise to the possibility of converting under-utilised road lanes into cycling or bus lanes.
There could be scope to pedestrianise some roads, he said, without giving specific examples.
Singapore University of Social Sciences transport economist Walter Theseira suggested that the downtown core area would be a plausible location to reclaim road lanes, though he noted the difficulty of identifying which roads could be converted without access to road-use data from the authorities.
He pointed to how the Government has reclaimed road lanes from Bencoolen Street - Singapore's first transit priority corridor that prioritises buses - and said the downtown is a local area to do so as "it has excellent public transport connectivity ".
On roads that could be pedestrianised, he floated smaller roads like Ann Siang Hill near Chinatown as possibilities. "The smaller roads in the downtown core are largely just used for parking now and accessing the retail shops there. With district parking and public transport, people don't need to drive down those roads," he said.
Mr Leow Bok Wee, a smart mobility consultant at Vertix Asia-Pacific, said it will be possible to take away road space at areas like the central business district where public transport is widely accessible.
But he added that the authorities should conduct traffic impact assessments and simulations before making such a move.
Related Story
What others have done about road space during Covid-19
In heartland areas, the authorities have taken away road space for cycling paths in certain places, for instance, at a 100m stretch along Jelapang Road in Bukit Panjang.
But Dr Theseira said it could be harder to do so more widely, given that roads in heartland areas are generally important ones that allow for movement through the town.
Mr Kelvin Foo, managing director of traffic and transport consultancy TTS Group, reckons it would be difficult to find roads that are under-used as these are usually planned on the basis that they will be well used. "Roads that are not well used are in areas like Lim Chu Kang, or (if they are) in areas that are a bit secluded, they are there for essential reasons."
Mr Foo added that any move to take away road space should be done gradually, and in tandem with other policies such as reducing the vehicle population.
He also noted that it would be challenging to plan permanent schemes based on the current Covid-19 situation, as traffic volumes could return to previous levels after the pandemic is over.
Mr Leow said his firm has observed up to a 30 per cent drop in traffic volumes around Singapore compared with before Covid-19, but the gap has been narrowing.
Meanwhile, transport economist Michael Li suggested that the authorities consider having bus lanes on busy roads as well, to improve public bus commutes. "This would benefit both commuters and bus operators who will enjoy quick turnaround timings," said Dr Li.
Dr Theseira said the authorities have been exploring alternative uses for road space that support different forms of mobility for some time, but the lower travel demand due to Covid-19 has provided an opportunity for them to possibly bring some of these plans forward.
Last Thursday, Mr Ong also said the growth in telecommuting and staggered working hours due to the pandemic has created more sustainable travel patterns. MOT will look into making some of these changes permanent, he added.
Transport infrastructure expert Raymond Ong from the National University of Singapore said such changes, if pushed through, will reduce passenger loads on trains. This will in turn lead to less wear and tear of both trains and rails, which will bring down maintenance costs. He added that the changes will also give operators leeway to optimise train frequencies and thus further manage costs.
Bishan-Toa Payoh GRC MP Saktiandi Supaat, chairman of the Government Parliamentary Committee for Transport, said the suggestion was feasible.
He added: "We have to move fast on this to encourage some of these work commuting patterns... and to make it comfortable for commuters... so they can be more productive at the end destinations for work and family."
The PAP often get the Straits Times pawns to cite "experts" to soften the ground and justify some impending policies to the citizens
Experts see scope for taking away road space from cars to make way for buses, cyclists or pedestrians downtown
A cycling path being built outside Covenant Evangelical Free Church in Jelapang Road. In heartland areas, the authorities have taken away road space for cycling paths in certain places, for instance, at a 100m stretch along Jelapang Road in Bukit Panjang. ST PHOTO: NG SOR LUAN
They share views on MOT plans to reimagine road infrastructure amid Covid-19 travel shifts
Toh Ting Wei
Singapore's downtown is an area where the authorities could take away road space from cars to make way for public buses, cyclists or pedestrians, said transport experts.
Doing so would bring about multiple benefits, such as revitalising street-level retail and making public transport smoother and more attractive, they added.
They were giving their take on plans by the Ministry of Transport (MOT) to make use of the opportunity provided by the Covid-19 pandemic to reimagine road infrastructure here. Transport Minister Ong Ye Kung said the pandemic has reduced traffic and led to new travel patterns, giving rise to the possibility of converting under-utilised road lanes into cycling or bus lanes.
There could be scope to pedestrianise some roads, he said, without giving specific examples.
Singapore University of Social Sciences transport economist Walter Theseira suggested that the downtown core area would be a plausible location to reclaim road lanes, though he noted the difficulty of identifying which roads could be converted without access to road-use data from the authorities.
He pointed to how the Government has reclaimed road lanes from Bencoolen Street - Singapore's first transit priority corridor that prioritises buses - and said the downtown is a local area to do so as "it has excellent public transport connectivity ".
On roads that could be pedestrianised, he floated smaller roads like Ann Siang Hill near Chinatown as possibilities. "The smaller roads in the downtown core are largely just used for parking now and accessing the retail shops there. With district parking and public transport, people don't need to drive down those roads," he said.
Mr Leow Bok Wee, a smart mobility consultant at Vertix Asia-Pacific, said it will be possible to take away road space at areas like the central business district where public transport is widely accessible.
But he added that the authorities should conduct traffic impact assessments and simulations before making such a move.
Related Story
What others have done about road space during Covid-19
In heartland areas, the authorities have taken away road space for cycling paths in certain places, for instance, at a 100m stretch along Jelapang Road in Bukit Panjang.
But Dr Theseira said it could be harder to do so more widely, given that roads in heartland areas are generally important ones that allow for movement through the town.
Mr Kelvin Foo, managing director of traffic and transport consultancy TTS Group, reckons it would be difficult to find roads that are under-used as these are usually planned on the basis that they will be well used. "Roads that are not well used are in areas like Lim Chu Kang, or (if they are) in areas that are a bit secluded, they are there for essential reasons."
Mr Foo added that any move to take away road space should be done gradually, and in tandem with other policies such as reducing the vehicle population.
He also noted that it would be challenging to plan permanent schemes based on the current Covid-19 situation, as traffic volumes could return to previous levels after the pandemic is over.
Mr Leow said his firm has observed up to a 30 per cent drop in traffic volumes around Singapore compared with before Covid-19, but the gap has been narrowing.
Meanwhile, transport economist Michael Li suggested that the authorities consider having bus lanes on busy roads as well, to improve public bus commutes. "This would benefit both commuters and bus operators who will enjoy quick turnaround timings," said Dr Li.
Dr Theseira said the authorities have been exploring alternative uses for road space that support different forms of mobility for some time, but the lower travel demand due to Covid-19 has provided an opportunity for them to possibly bring some of these plans forward.
Last Thursday, Mr Ong also said the growth in telecommuting and staggered working hours due to the pandemic has created more sustainable travel patterns. MOT will look into making some of these changes permanent, he added.
Transport infrastructure expert Raymond Ong from the National University of Singapore said such changes, if pushed through, will reduce passenger loads on trains. This will in turn lead to less wear and tear of both trains and rails, which will bring down maintenance costs. He added that the changes will also give operators leeway to optimise train frequencies and thus further manage costs.
Bishan-Toa Payoh GRC MP Saktiandi Supaat, chairman of the Government Parliamentary Committee for Transport, said the suggestion was feasible.
He added: "We have to move fast on this to encourage some of these work commuting patterns... and to make it comfortable for commuters... so they can be more productive at the end destinations for work and family."
Last edited: