Man fined for selling fake contact lenses

[General Veers]

Man fined for selling fake contact lenses
By Claire Huang | Posted: 20 February 2012 1907 hrs

SINGAPORE: A 52-year-old man on Monday pleaded guilty and was fined S$12,000 for selling fake contact lenses.

Wong Chow Fatt admitted to three charges relating to the purchase and supply of counterfeit contact lenses, between April and May last year.

He bought 30 boxes of fake "FreshLook ColorBlends" contact lenses from an optometrist for S$225 and went on to sell them for a total profit of S$15.

The market value of one box of the real deal is S$25.

For this police charge, Wong was fined S$6,000.

For supplying contact lenses presented with false information of the manufacturer, Wong contravened the Health Sciences Authority's (HSA) Health Products Act and was fined S$3,000 on each of two similar charges.

Wong is one of seven men charged in court on Monday with such offences.

The other six are 29-year-old Koh Peng Kiat, 26-year-old Neo Teck Soon, 34-year-old Goh Peck Joo, 31-year-old Ong Wei Yee, 51-year-old Ng Cheng Peow, and 47-year-old Pae Bee Kian.

According to court documents, CIBAvision (Singapore) Private Limited was notified in June 2011 that 108 boxes of "FreshLook ColorBlends" contact lenses were counterfeit.

The lenses were sent in by three optical retail outlets in Woodlands, Joo Chiat and Jurong West for exchange.

A total of 115 boxes of the lenses were seized from CIBAvision and the outlets.

The contact lenses were tested and found to be fake.

This is the first time HSA has pressed charges under the Health Products Act, where an offender faces a fine of up to S$100,000 and / or jail term of up to three years.

- CNA/wk

 

[General Veers]

Counterfeit coloured contact lenses sold at shops
By Sharon See | Posted: 20 July 2011 1317 hrs

SINGAPORE: The Health Sciences Authority (HSA) said it found counterfeit coloured contact lenses being sold in local optical shops in June.

The counterfeits are imitations of "FreshLook ColorBlends" by CIBA VISION and have been found to be "unsafe and of poor quality".

This is the first known case of counterfeit health products found with legitimate suppliers.

HSA said it has seized more than 100 boxes from at least five optical shops islandwide.

The counterfeits look almost authentic, apart from typographical errors on the packaging.

It is difficult to differentiate between the authentic and counterfeit lenses with the naked eye.

Chan Cheng Leng, Division Director, Enforcement, Health Sciences Authority, said: "Our laboratories have found that the lens quality is very different from the authentic product.

"One glaring difference is that the colour pigments, which are supposed to be on the external surface of the lenses of the authentic products were found on the internal surface of the contact lens. But those are not visible to the naked eye."

HSA said lab tests also found that the storage liquid was not sterile and was contaminated with a bacteria called Pseudomonas aeruginosa - a harmful bacteria that has been known to cause eye infections in contact lens users.

So far, HSA said one consumer has reported extreme discomfort when she tried to wear the counterfeit lenses.

The unnamed woman, who is in her 30s, and wanted to remain anonymous, reportedly removed the lenses immediately when she could not close her eyes after wearing them.

In a statement, CIBA VISION said this is the first time its lenses have been counterfeited.

The company was alerted to this when some optical shops tried to exchange the counterfeit products with CIBA VISION.

Upon investigation, CIBA VISION confirmed the products were counterfeits as they were not manufactured by them.

HSA said previous cases of counterfeit health products were largely confined to the black market or internet, and they mostly involved imitations of "lifestyle" drugs like erectile dysfunction medicines such as Viagra and Cialis.

HSA said the case is still under investigation. So far, more than 10 people have been questioned by HSA in connection with this case.

"Based on our preliminary investigations, at least five optical shops are being investigated. All counterfeit products have been withdrawn from these shops, and we have stepped up our surveillance and enforcement activities in the optical shops. Our findings so far is that the shops that have been investigated or undergoing surveillance, the products are in order," said Chan.

It is unclear if the retailers knew the products are counterfeits, but HSA said they were "knowingly not buying from an authorised dealer" - as they got some 50 per cent savings when getting them even though they were probably sold to consumers at the same price as the authentic products.

Anyone found guilty of supplying counterfeit medical devices faces a fine of up to S$100,000 or three years' jail.

The public can contact HSA's Enforcement Branch at 68663485 to report any counterfeit health products.

- CNA/fa/ls