ICA might want to avail the Camera footage. The versions are so different that it requires an indepedent party to investigate. Since when passports have to be copied for lodging a complaint.
I believe the query was having a dedicated "Singapore Passport" channel which the whole world do for their respective citizens but not us. Thats the main query and it was not answered.
Someone should raise this in parliament.
Bad turn of events at airport after complaining to ICA officer
I WISH to relate the treatment I received at the hands of Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (ICA) officers at Changi Airport on Monday.
When I arrived on a Jetstar flight from Hong Kong at about 3.30pm, there was only one counter for Singapore passport holders like myself but about five or six for foreigners, so the queue was quite long.
When it was finally my turn, and while my passport was being stamped, I remarked to the ICA officer that they should open another counter for Singapore residents and that it was unacceptable that locals had to suffer a longer queue than foreigners.
Another ICA officer (let me call him Mr K) who was standing nearby overheard my remarks. He immediately grabbed my passport as I was leaving. He then said my remarks were a slander on the Singapore Government and asked me to follow him and started walking away.
I asked him to return the passport to me, but he refused. He then passed my passport to his "duty officer". The "duty officer" did not say anything but proceeded to photocopy my passport. When I asked him why he was doing that, he refused to answer me.
While I was speaking with the "duty officer", Mr K continued his tirade against me. The "duty officer" did nothing to dissuade him.
Needless to say, I am very dissatisfied with the level of service and the rudeness shown by the ICA officers. I was treated like a common criminal throughout the whole incident. Is complaining about service shortcomings slandering the Government?
Wang Chen Yong
Long queue? Passenger cleared immigration in 6min
SEVERAL points in the Forum Online letter last Thursday by Mr Wang Chen Yong, 'Bad turn of events at airport after complaining to ICA officer', need to be corrected.
First, Mr Wang asserted that there was only one counter open for Singapore citizens/permanent residents. This is not correct. The fact is that Singaporeans can use all the other counters which are, as their designation 'All Passports' suggests, open for use by all passport holders. In addition, as a Singaporean, he can also use the automated lanes.
Second, his remark that the queue at the Singapore citizens/PRs counter was longer than other counters was also inaccurate. We have retrieved our records and on examination, we have determined that in fact all counters at the time when he was lining up had about 10 travellers each.
When Mr Wang demanded that an Immigration and Checkpoints Authority officer on duty open another Singapore citizens/PRs counter, the officer explained that he was performing security observation duties and was unable to vacate his post. Mr Wang was dissatisfied and insisted on making a complaint. He was therefore referred to the senior immigration officer on duty. When the senior officer tried to explain to Mr Wang that he could use all other counters or automated clearance channels in future, Mr Wang remained agitated and wanted to lodge a complaint. His passport was then photocopied for the complaint to be registered and the incident recorded by the duty officer in his daily report.
Our records show that Mr Wang joined the queue at 3.07pm. He was cleared at 3.13pm. It took only six minutes for him to clear immigration, which included his conversations with our officers.
Chia Hui Keng (Ms)
I believe the query was having a dedicated "Singapore Passport" channel which the whole world do for their respective citizens but not us. Thats the main query and it was not answered.
Someone should raise this in parliament.
Bad turn of events at airport after complaining to ICA officer
I WISH to relate the treatment I received at the hands of Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (ICA) officers at Changi Airport on Monday.
When I arrived on a Jetstar flight from Hong Kong at about 3.30pm, there was only one counter for Singapore passport holders like myself but about five or six for foreigners, so the queue was quite long.
When it was finally my turn, and while my passport was being stamped, I remarked to the ICA officer that they should open another counter for Singapore residents and that it was unacceptable that locals had to suffer a longer queue than foreigners.
Another ICA officer (let me call him Mr K) who was standing nearby overheard my remarks. He immediately grabbed my passport as I was leaving. He then said my remarks were a slander on the Singapore Government and asked me to follow him and started walking away.
I asked him to return the passport to me, but he refused. He then passed my passport to his "duty officer". The "duty officer" did not say anything but proceeded to photocopy my passport. When I asked him why he was doing that, he refused to answer me.
While I was speaking with the "duty officer", Mr K continued his tirade against me. The "duty officer" did nothing to dissuade him.
Needless to say, I am very dissatisfied with the level of service and the rudeness shown by the ICA officers. I was treated like a common criminal throughout the whole incident. Is complaining about service shortcomings slandering the Government?
Wang Chen Yong
Long queue? Passenger cleared immigration in 6min
SEVERAL points in the Forum Online letter last Thursday by Mr Wang Chen Yong, 'Bad turn of events at airport after complaining to ICA officer', need to be corrected.
First, Mr Wang asserted that there was only one counter open for Singapore citizens/permanent residents. This is not correct. The fact is that Singaporeans can use all the other counters which are, as their designation 'All Passports' suggests, open for use by all passport holders. In addition, as a Singaporean, he can also use the automated lanes.
Second, his remark that the queue at the Singapore citizens/PRs counter was longer than other counters was also inaccurate. We have retrieved our records and on examination, we have determined that in fact all counters at the time when he was lining up had about 10 travellers each.
When Mr Wang demanded that an Immigration and Checkpoints Authority officer on duty open another Singapore citizens/PRs counter, the officer explained that he was performing security observation duties and was unable to vacate his post. Mr Wang was dissatisfied and insisted on making a complaint. He was therefore referred to the senior immigration officer on duty. When the senior officer tried to explain to Mr Wang that he could use all other counters or automated clearance channels in future, Mr Wang remained agitated and wanted to lodge a complaint. His passport was then photocopied for the complaint to be registered and the incident recorded by the duty officer in his daily report.
Our records show that Mr Wang joined the queue at 3.07pm. He was cleared at 3.13pm. It took only six minutes for him to clear immigration, which included his conversations with our officers.
Chia Hui Keng (Ms)