• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Doctor killed by patient in clinic!

nayr69sg

Super Moderator
Staff member
SuperMod
Joined
Apr 25, 2010
Messages
17,144
Points
113
https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/red-deer-clinic-doctor-attacked-1.5681052

Red Deer doctor dies after attack at walk-in medical clinic
Social Sharing
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
Eyewitness says attacker was armed with hammer and machete

janice-johnston.jpg

Janice Johnston · CBC News · Posted: Aug 10, 2020 2:48 PM MT | Last Updated: 13 minutes ago

village-mall-clinic.jpg

The scene outside the Village Mall walk-in clinic in Red Deer on Monday morning after a doctor was attacked inside the clinic. (Kalisha Mendonsa/Lacombe Online/Sunny 94)
A Red Deer physician died Monday after he was attacked in an examination room at the Village Mall walk-in clinic.
RCMP said one man is in custody and the major crimes unit has taken over what police called "an active homicide investigation."
Anina Mullin said she was in the clinic with her 13-year-old daughter when she suddenly heard screams coming from an examination room.
She heard someone yell, "Help me, help me. Call 911."
Mullin said it sounded like the victim was trying to save himself and fight off the attacker.
She also heard banging. She said a panicked receptionist enlisted help from two male patients.
They tried to get into the room, but Mullin said someone slammed the door in their faces. They then ran to reception area, where Mullin was standing, waiting to be checked in.
"So I just grabbed my daughter's hand ... and we just ran out the door as fast as we could," she said.
The two men pushed against the door from the outside to make sure the attacker couldn't escape.
As Mullin watched from her car, police, paramedics and the fire department arrived outside the clinic.
"One of the cops went to the door with his gun drawn and poked his head in," Mullin said. "I heard him yell, 'Put that down or I will shoot.'"
She said someone threw a blood-soaked hammer at the police, which flew out the door onto the cement pad in front of the clinic.
She heard the officer order the man to put a machete down. Then officers rushed inside the clinic.
Mullin saw officers lead out a man she described as "huge" who was wearing a grey hoodie and baggy grey pants. She said he had a disposable face mask that wasn't covering his mouth, so she could see him with "kind of a smirk on his face."
'Covered in blood'
Mullin watched in horror as her long-time family doctor was taken out on a stretcher.
"He was covered in blood from his head to his belt area. They were applying pressure to his forehead."
At this time, CBC News is not naming the doctor.
Mullin described her doctor as "amazing."
While she continued to watch, Mullin saw other staff members pour out of the clinic at 6230 50th Ave.
"They were just beside themselves," she said. "It was awful."
 
I think it is this Dr.

https://www.ratemds.com/doctor-ratings/130346/Dr-Annegret-Kotze-Red+Deer-AB.html

Ratings for Dr. Annegret Kotze

Staff5
Punctuality5
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

This Doctor needs more love. She is amazing. Direct, honest and caring. Everything a doctor should be. She fights for her patients. She’s blunt. But that’s a good thing.

0Helpful?Flag
June 1, 2020

Staff5
Punctuality4
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

Have only seen a few times but she knew right away when I had vertigo and how to diagnose plus today took my headaches seriously and made me aware of high blood pressure plus a cat scan is to be done. She took the time to study what medication i take and listen to my family history. I am pleased with her thoroughness. I would recommend this doctor. I didn't feel rushed or disregarded.

0Helpful?Flag
April 25, 2019

Staff4
Punctuality2
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

She’s terrible! I had a bleeding during my pregnancy and I need to go walk-in coz my famiky doctor is not available by that time and I asked her if I can hear my baby’s heartbeat. She got the doppler but she said that it will not work since it’s too early. But I told her that I can already hear my baby’s heartbeat during my family doctor’s appointment. She told me that I have a threatening miscarriage but I felt how the way she’s saying that I already lost my baby and I can’t do anything about it. Good thing that I don’t listen to her, after that I tried to call my family doctor clinic again and told them what this doctor said. They immediately see me, then I hear my baby’s heartbeat. My baby is fine now.

0Helpful?Flag
October 15, 2018

Staff2
Punctuality2
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

She didn't even try to consider what I was trying to say about my symptoms and continued to cut me off. It felt like I was wasting her time and she didn't want to see me. I will never go back to see her again. She even made a joke about how I have to lose weight by giving me options like not eating at all, a doctor should not be saying this to her patients. I still can't believe she said that to me.

0Helpful?Flag
October 11, 2018

Staff5
Punctuality5
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

I have seen Kotze a few times now and I must say I feel the opposite of all these comments. She is the first doctor I have seen for my anxiety and depression that doesn't think I'm over reacting. She has gotten me on the right path to resolving many of my health issues and I am so grateful.

1Helpful?Flag
August 6, 2018

Staff1
Punctuality1
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Absolutely terrible!!! Wouldn't let me speak wouldn't let me list my symptoms and actually said she wouldn't listen to me! I have never left a business so upset, especially a doctor's office. Drive to another doctor, listed my symptoms and immediately was being taken seriously and tested

0Helpful?Flag
January 25, 2018

Staff3
Punctuality4
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Just to back up what everyone else is saying, terrible Dr. wouldn’t listen to me about my problems and just said, “look at you, your good”! She’s a useless cook!!

0Helpful?Flag
October 21, 2017

Staff1
Punctuality1
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Had a very unpleasant experience with this doctor, I went it to see her for a physical, as I have had health issues in the past she made me feel like I was wasting her time and she was unconcerned about how I was feeling, she said that I didn't look too underweight, did not weigh me or see how tall I was, had a terrible attitude toward the whole appointment

1Helpful?Flag
March 22, 2017

Staff4
Punctuality2
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Wouldn't let me talk. Didn't ask my symptoms, didn't ask why I thought I need specific blood tests. I would never go see her again. The doctors are Discovery Medical Clinic are amazing, I feel the addition of Dr. Kotze will reflect badly on the clinic.

1Helpful?Flag
January 27, 2017

Staff5
Punctuality5
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

I have been seeing Dr. Kotze for over 5 years now. She saved my life, I have had 4 arterial blood clots and she is the reason I am alive, she is the one that got an emergency CT scan when she looked at the leg! after 3 other Dr's saying it was nothing I was rushed to Edmonton for emergency surgery to save my life and my leg. 1. She is positive. 2. Caring 3. Knows her patients. 4.Knows what to do. When these Dr's see over 55 patients from 8:30 till 1:00 pm in a day it is up to the patient to be concise with what their symptoms are, so that she has more time to help them. Blame the Federal and Provincial Governments for the lousy health care not the Dr.'s. Just my thoughts Ms.J Helm
 
Being a doctor could be more dangerous than catching Covid.
 
Maybe this Dr

https://www.ratemds.com/doctor-ratings/76670/Dr-Stephen-Nel-Red+Deer-AB.html

Ratings for Dr. Stephen Nel

Staff3
Punctuality4
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

I went to see Dr Nel last year after I had come out of hospital,he was very understanding and answered all my questions, he took his time,I wasn't rushed,he was very helpful,he says it like it is,if you can't handle that then dont go to this Dr,he helped me a lot that day.

0Helpful?Flag
July 24, 2020

Staff3
Punctuality4
Helpfulness3
Knowledge4

I had a fine experience with Dr. Nel. I go when he is not likely to be busy, I give him great information when I am there, I am cooperative with him and discuss things intelligently. Therefore I get the same things back from him.......

0Helpful?Flag
February 13, 2020

Staff4
Punctuality5
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

Stephen Nel is the best doctor I have encountered. Very knowledgeable and can relate to people and their circumstances.

0Helpful?Flag
January 14, 2020

Staff1
Punctuality3
Helpfulness4
Knowledge5

I saw Dr.Stephen Nel today he was very knowledgeable about my situation, had time to listen as it was genuinely trying to help me make better choices I was very impressed

0Helpful?Flag
August 13, 2019

Staff1
Punctuality1
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

The worst experience ever. Kicked me out if his office, just felt discriminated.

0Helpful?Flag
August 1, 2019

Staff2
Punctuality2
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Dr nel did contacted wcb stating i had a injury. But yet said i was fit for regular duties .im in construction and cant move my finger .thats not right .he does not understand my job duties.

0Helpful?Flag
July 27, 2018

Staff4
Punctuality2
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Not impressed at all. Waited 2 hours for him to tell me to come back so a female Doctor could do a pelvic exam. Thanks for wasting my time and assuming I would sue you for sexual misconduct.

0Helpful?Flag
March 27, 2017

Staff5
Punctuality5
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

Great Dr. Down to earth and non judgemental. Hard to get in sometimes but not his fault. It's a walk in clinic.

0Helpful?Flag
January 30, 2017

Staff5
Punctuality3
Helpfulness5
Knowledge5

Dr. Nel has been my family doctor since he moved to Red Deer. He was kind friendly and always happy and smiling back then and he still is. He always listens and takes his time with me and my family. He is one of a kind, nothing negative to say except you have to wait a long time sometimes to see him…..but he is lovely and worth waiting for.

0Helpful?Flag
September 2, 2014

Staff2
Punctuality1
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Don't bother -very judgemental-does not really listen just busy typing info into computer but does not bother to check prior visits-daughter went to & told to come back next am for results but he wasn't even there...try...you'll see
 
As you can see, the same doctor can be an angel and god send to one patient and the worst doctor and human being to another patient.

Doctoring is very difficult.

Often it is doctors who stick to prinicples that will have reviews like that.

those doctors who EVERYONE LOVES are usually the prata type flip flop all over do whatever the patient wants very flexible one patient will say good yeah stop medicine as you want another patient yeah take medicine it will help you. Whatever patient wants!

patients have no idea what a good doctor is really they just want what they want and believe
 
The other problem with doctor consult rooms is that it often only has ONE door to enter and exit. So it is extremely easy to corner the doctor in the room and kill him. Just stand at the door.

Also for privacy reasons often sound proof so cries for help cannot be heard either.

Basically doctor no different from prostitute when it comes to safety. If the client want to murder and decapitate you very easy. and no one to help prevent that from happening. All in a private room you can take your time.
 
Staff1
Punctuality1
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Absolutely terrible!!! Wouldn't let me speak wouldn't let me list my symptoms and actually said she wouldn't listen to me! I have never left a business so upset, especially a doctor's office. Drive to another doctor, listed my symptoms and immediately was being taken seriously and tested

Staff3
Punctuality4
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Just to back up what everyone else is saying, terrible Dr. wouldn’t listen to me about my problems and just said, “look at you, your good”! She’s a useless cook!!

Staff1
Punctuality1
Helpfulness1
Knowledge1

Had a very unpleasant experience with this doctor, I went it to see her for a physical, as I have had health issues in the past she made me feel like I was wasting her time and she was unconcerned about how I was feeling, she said that I didn't look too underweight, did not weigh me or see how tall I was, had a terrible attitude toward the whole appointment

Singapore's bastard equivalent - Christopher Cheok

DrChrisCheok.jpg


https://www.clarity-singapore.org/web1/index.php/about-us/board-of-directors
 
During army time?

haha, yah. The good ones were Dr John Wong and Dr Ang. This guy couldn't go far because of Dr Wong and Dr Ang. He took it out on NSFs like me for good fun. Fortunately, his assistant Dr Ivan Ong kept me alive. That's why when I knew your age, I asked if you know Dr Ivan. Christopher Cheok was so arrogant that went the medics at CMPB cursed him behind his back.
 
haha, yah. The good ones were Dr John Wong and Dr Ang. This guy couldn't go far because of Dr Wong and Dr Ang. He took it out on NSFs like me for good fun. Fortunately, his assistant Dr Ivan Ong kept me alive. That's why when I knew your age, I asked if you know Dr Ivan. Christopher Cheok was so arrogant that went the medics at CMPB cursed him behind his back.
Aiyah SAF is fucked up lah.

Seriously.

Only fucked up people join SAF.
 
Aiyah SAF is fucked up lah.

Seriously.

Only fucked up people join SAF.

After I left army, i read about some people like me who shared Christopher Cheok's hypocrisy online. It was comforting to know that I was not alone. There are good men, but if you are good, you will not survive regular service.

Look at Dr Ang's frustration, many top lawyers are behind him too.
 
Back
Top