• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Do you believe that civil service is politically impartial?

winnipegjets

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
Joined
Jul 19, 2011
Messages
27,854
Points
113
Civil servants not independent of elected Government, but they should be politically impartial: PM Lee

SINGAPORE - The civil service is not independent of the elected government, unlike the judiciary, which is a different branch of government, said Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.

Under Singapore's system, the civil service must serve the elected government of the day, and civil servants must therefore understand the political context, and the thinking of the political leadership.

This will ensure it will not come up with policies that are non-starters, but instead design policies that are not only sound but are also well-supported and can be well implemented, he said.

However, "civil servants should be politically impartial", he added.

"They should not be campaigning for or against a political party. They must not misuse state resources or powers for partisan political purposes, but neither should they shy away from carrying out their duties without fear or favour when a matter might prove to be politically controversial."

PM Lee said that it is for for these reasons that the officers in the service are not allowed to be members of political parties.

He was speaking at the annual Administrative Service Promotion Ceremony and Dinner held at Shangri-La Hotel where 65 public servants were promoted.

In a speech that touched on politics, policies, and the role of civil servants, Mr Lee also spelt out the the role of ministers.

Ministers look after the politics, sense the ground, decide the direction the country should take, sell the policies to the public and make them work.

At the same time, the minister must also master his ministry, and the policies he is responsible for, said PM Lee.

"He is not a non-executive chairman, presiding passively over an organisation that runs fine without him, while he busies himself with politics."

He has to be hands on, articulate a clear strategy for his ministry to serve the needs and meet the aspirations of the people, make sure the Permanent Secretary does a good job in implementing policy and operating the ministry, and provide political guidance to the civil service to deliver results.

At the same time he must protect civil servants from political interference, and he must not involve them in political activities.

The clear roles of civil servants and ministers have worked well, he said.

"There will always be a fine balance - between the civil service being neutral and non-political, and being politically sensitive and responsive," he noted.

"This is inherent in the role of the civil service, to work with and for political leaders, in a political environment, and yet be detached from politics. It is a fine balance which has always been required, and which we must continue to maintain."
 
The civil service is not independent of the elected government, unlike the judiciary, which is a different branch of government

Most sinkees believe that the judiciary serves the government. It is not independent. Pinky should just be honest and tell the truth.

Likewise for the civil service. A recent example is how it went after the WP town council. It did the dirty work for the PAP.
 
At the same time, the minister must also master his ministry, and the policies he is responsible for, said PM Lee

By that standard, most of his ministers have fallen shot. The obvious one is the transport minister and the education ministers.

So, how does he judge the minister without portfolio? Or minister fu?
 
Most sinkees believe that the judiciary serves the government. It is not independent. Pinky should just be honest and tell the truth.

Likewise for the civil service. A recent example is how it went after the WP town council. It did the dirty work for the PAP.

who appoints the CJ and AG>>>????
 
By that standard, most of his ministers have fallen shot. The obvious one is the transport minister and the education ministers.

So, how does he judge the minister without portfolio? Or minister fu?

you forgot the 50 yr rain minister who oso champions mozzies........... wonder if his sons now sg citizens and will serve NS
 
No. There are sinkies working in the civil service and sinkies are voters. Unless we remove all sinkies from civil service, it can never be politically impartial.
 
They are politically impartial to whoever pays their paycheck.unless chee figures out how to become a billlionaire soon
 
Not unless you tell us that Grace Fu's got a prick :p
 
only daft sinkies will believe that civil service is impartial, who doesn't know that in civil service, if you are an opposition supporter, your career end on the spot.
 
However, "civil servants should be politically impartial", he added.

Civil servants should be politically impartial, but the top civil servant in each ministry reports to a prominent member of a political party. ;)
 
only daft sinkies will believe that civil service is impartial, who doesn't know that in civil service, if you are an opposition supporter, your career end on the spot.

Tan Jee Say was an opposition supporter for years. Yet he rose to be a principal private secretary. He did pretty well in the civil service.
 
Tan Jee Say was an opposition supporter for years. Yet he rose to be a principal private secretary. He did pretty well in the civil service.

His boss, the woodpecker, claimed that TJS was not suitable to be a perm sec. However he also said that TJS was a hardworking and competent principal private secretary. ;)
 
His boss, the woodpecker, claimed that TJS was not suitable to be a perm sec. However he also said that TJS was a hardworking and competent principal private secretary. ;)

A principal private secretary is itself a very highly ranked civil servant. If you can hold that sort of appointment, you probably are doing better than over 90% of the civil service.
 
A principal private secretary is itself a very highly ranked civil servant. If you can hold that sort of appointment, you probably are doing better than over 90% of the civil service.

There are a few former pps who are now ministars. There is also one former pps who is now a perm sec and married to an mp. ;)
 
The Admin Service sadly began to be politicised in the late 90s. The old guards like Ngiam, Pillay, Hochstadt, Boggars, Sim etc had left and the Scholars began to insight for positions. The less capable ones chose to easier way to advance their career. That speech by LHL is disgraceful.

When Pillay was Perm Sec and was Chairman of SIA and Ngiam who was also a Perm sec and was Chairman of DBS, Devan Nair complained to the old man that SIA Unions are not member of NTUC and DBS did not allow staff to join a union. Both Perm Secs told Nair to fuck off.
 
Back
Top