http://tnp.sg/news/story/0,4136,203700,00.html?
Pay $167 a month for CREDIT CARD BRIDES
Matchmaking agency ties up with credit card for monthly instalment plan for Vietnamese brides
By Crystal Chan
June 01, 2009
NOVEL IDEA: Agency owner Mark Lin with a standee of a Vietnamese bride. --TNP PICTURES: NG XI JIE
WANT a Vietnamese bride? It will cost you just $167 a month. And all you need is a Diners Club credit card.
If that sounds like a sales pitch, it is.
It is the latest marketing tactic by matchmaking agency Vietnam Brides International.
The actual cost of $8,000 can be split up over four years, interest-free, for those who pay with Diners.
Agency owner Mark Lin told The New Paper on Sunday that Diners Club approached him in February, offering to install a credit card terminal for him without charge.
And the scheme started the same month. He said: 'Since it's free, why not?'
Mr Bernard Tay, assistant general manager (sales and marketing) for Diners Club (Singapore), said: 'So long as the cardholders have a valid credit limit, they qualify for the repayment scheme.'
He was quick to differentiate between an instalment plan and a hire purchase agreement.
He said: 'We won't take back the bride if the customer defaults on payments. It's not like hire purchase where we take back the product if the customer doesn't pay up by the due date.'
Debt recovery
Under the instalment plan, Diners Club's monthly interest rate of 2 per cent of the outstanding amount will kick in if the customer fails to pay by the due date.
Mr Tay added: 'If the customers still don't repay, we'll have other ways to recover the debt.'
No one has taken up this offer yet, but Mr Tay said: 'Matchmaking is considered a niche service so demand is generally lower. It's not every day that people need a foreign bride.'
Vietnam Brides International isn't the first to offer an instalment scheme for brides.
In April 2007, matchmaking agency Mr Cupid raised eyebrows by offering China brides for a downpayment of just $1.
The rest of the $6,000 bill was to be paid in monthly instalments over 10 months.
Mr Cupid has since closed its Singapore office as it is changing its business strategy.
Ethical questions
But is it ethical for someone to pay for a bride in monthly instalments, just like how people pay for electrical appliances and cars?
Mr Tay said: 'We don't make a moral judgement on the business set-up of our merchant partners. For us, it's more important that the business is legitimate.'
Mr Lin insists that he is not treating the women as commodities.
He said in Mandarin: 'It's just a service that I'm offering to customers. I've got clients asking if they can pay with Visa or Mastercard so it shows there's a demand for instalment payments.'
He denies using the instalment plan as a means to push his girls.
Mr Lin said: 'Times are bad and paying in instalments would mean not having to burn a hole in one's pocket since there's no interest.
'Even if the customer defaults on payment, I'm not the one losing money.'
In credit card payments, the card issuer pays the merchant upfront. If the customer defaults on repayment, the card issuer can take legal action to recover the debt.
Last year, three of Mr Lin's customers backed out of marriages when they lost money in the stock marketcrash.
They had each paid a deposit of $1,000 and told Mr Lin they would rather forfeit it than spend more money to complete the transaction.
Mr Lin said that if his business was booming, he would not mind paying to install Visa and Mastercard terminals.
It costs about $700 to install Visa and Mastercard terminals, with an annual subscription fee of about $100, checks with local banks show.
In the current economic climate, Mr Lin is more cost-conscious, but does not mind paying Diners Club its usual 3 per cent commission.
Other agencies specialising in foreign brides baulk at the idea.
Mr Janson Ong of Life Partner Matchmaker, which charges $10,000 for a bride, said the large amount does not make credit card payments feasible.
He said: 'How many people have such high credit limits?'
And he's against instalments 'because we could be encouraging cash-strapped men to marry'.
He said: 'If the groom can't afford the lump sum of $10,000, he's probably financially unstable.
'It could mean problems for the bride in future. In such situations, I can't be sure the man is able to care for her.'
Mr Francis Toh, who runs First Overseas International Matchmaker, said his clients usually pay with cheques or cash.
He said: 'It's just not feasible to have credit card payments. Matchmaking agencies are not supermarkets or restaurants where there are transactions every day.
'Unless I have a high sales volume, I won't consider allowing credit card payments because the installation and annual subscription fees don't justify it.'
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Don't treat Vietnamese brides like consumer goods
PRIVATE equity investor Alvin Lim, 44, has a Diners Club credit card but he will never consider a monthly repayment scheme for a bride.
On Valentine's Day last year, Mr Lim married Ms Mary Nguyen, 21, whom he met through Vietnam Brides International.
He told The New Paper on Sunday that it is always better to be able to afford something than to pay in instalments, especially when the annual interest rates are as high as 24 per cent for late payments.
When told that Vietnam Brides International has a zero-interest repayment scheme for Diners Club cardholders, Mr Lim said: 'I'd rather save up the money first before getting married. You're talking about a life-time commitment.
'If you can't afford it, you shouldn't get married in the first place. If you can't afford the repayment just months into the marriage, the banks could sue you.'
Ms Nguyen feels the instalment plan is just another way for agents to make money.
She said: 'I think that $8,000 for a bride is so expensive. It makes me wonder if the agents are doing a service or are just looking to sell us off.
'This instalment plan will only make it easier for agents to marry the girls off.'
Civil servant Alex Lee, 43, who is married to a Vietnamese woman, felt that the instalment plan makes the brides look like consumer products.
He said: 'Treating the brides as products will cheapen the institution of marriage and demean the woman.'
Still, he acknowledged that most people are mature enough to think for themselves.
He said: 'People will marry when they are ready to, not because of a promotion like that.
'The instalment plan is a creative way of attracting customers, but I doubt it will be a major factor for people who are serious about marriage.'
Family counsellor Charles Lee warned that such schemes could lead to men making hasty decisions even if they cannot afford to support a family.
Another counsellor, Mr David Lim, said: 'The woman may think her husband is cash-strapped and she could start having misgivings about the marriage.'
But Mr Lee said the flip side is that some Vietnamese girls aren't picky so long as they marry a Singaporean.
He said: 'So you must also ask: Are they sincerely looking for a husband or just a way out of poverty?'.