- Joined
- Aug 8, 2008
- Messages
- 6,070
- Points
- 83
Grandma was guerilla warrior against Japs during WW2, see the medal won on her chest!? Fought her live against death from Japs under the same flag that is being raised. Of course she will struggle to standup!
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/輪椅婆婆聽國歌肅立民主派質疑虐老-建制派反駁為愛國抗日老戰士-132300205.html
輪椅婆婆聽國歌肅立民主派質疑虐老 建制派反駁為愛國抗日老戰士
星島日報
18.2k 人追蹤
2019年5月2日 下午9:23
宣傳片中坐輪椅的婆婆,聽國歌時肅立。國歌快閃片段截圖
【星島日報報道】「香港各界青少年活動委員會」近日推出3分鐘國歌短片,找來名人上鏡獻唱,還有個坐輪椅的老婦,撐住拐杖、由旁人攙扶下起身肅立唱歌。公民黨立法會議員郭家麒今日在法案委員會上批評,勉強老人家聽到國歌起身顯示愛國精神是「低級趣味」,要求政制及內地事務局長聶德權譴責做法是傷害老人家,擔心日後立法後強迫長者站立、強迫啞巴唱國歌。
立法會議員張超雄指出,草案列明奏唱國歌時出席人士需要肅立和舉止莊重,政府雖曾公開解釋,若無侮辱國歌的意圖便不屬違法,但宣傳片或會誤導公眾行動不便亦必須肅立,要求政府澄清。
聶德權解釋,宣傳片並非政府製作。他又指,如果片段中的婆婆想起身表達對國歌的尊重,她又起到身,事件完全無問題。他又重申,若因身體狀况而無法站立,在奏唱國歌場合不站立是無問題。
民建聯的漁農界議員何俊賢就反駁議員講法,稱片中的婆婆是東江縱隊抗日老戰士,非常有愛國情懷,郭家麒稱勉強老人講法是侮辱。
民建聯陳恒鑌亦加入澄清,片段中的長者是一名抗日的老戰士,經歷過國家受苦難的日子,認為國家應該受到尊重,平時借助輪椅行路,但可以站起來,每次聽到國歌時都會盡量站起來以示尊重,片段內容真人真事,並非製作人創作出來
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/政情網上行-站立唱國歌-110000263.html
【政情網上行】站立唱國歌
now.com 新聞
2.6k 人追蹤
2019年5月2日 下午7:00
【政情網上行】站立唱國歌
【強制站立?】
青年團體發起國歌快閃活動
除咗有政商界及藝人響應
片段中仲有一位
坐輪椅嘅婆婆
聽到國歌就站起來
國歌法法案委員會上
公民黨郭家麒質問聶德權
法例會唔會虐待殘疾人士
#國歌法 #立法會 #聶德權 #郭家麒
#香港新聞 #政治新聞
#政情網上行
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/%E8%BC%AA%E6%A4%85%E5%A9%86%E5%A9%86%E8%81%BD%E5%9C%8B%E6 %AD%8C%E8%82%85%E7%AB%8B%E6%B0%91%E4%B8%BB%E6%B4%BE%E8%B3%AA%E7%96%91%E8%99 %90%E8%80%81-%E5%BB%BA%E5%88%B6%E6%B4%BE%E5%8F%8D%E9%A7%81%E7%82%BA%E6%84% 9B%E5%9C%8B%E6%8A%97%E6%97%A5%E8%80%81%E6%88%B0%E5%A3%AB-132300205.html
Wheelchair mother-in-law listens to the national anthem, and the democratic party questioned the elder abuse. The establishmentist refuted the patriotic anti-Japanese warrior.
[Sing Tao Daily]
Sing Tao Daily
18.2k person tracking
May 2, 2019, 9:23 PM
The mother-in-law who was in a wheelchair in the propaganda film stood up when listening to the national anthem. National Anthem Flash Clip Screenshot
[Sing Tao Daily News] "Hong Kong Youth Activities Committee" recently launched a three-minute national anthem short film, looking for celebrities to sing on the mirror, and an elderly woman in a wheelchair, holding a cane, and helping others to stand up and sing. The Citizens Party Legislative Council member, Mr Kwok Ka-wai, criticized the Bills Committee today. It is "low-level interest" to force the elderly to hear the national anthem and show that patriotism is a "low-level interest". The Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs, Nie De-kwong, has condemned the practice of harming the elderly and fearing that the elderly will be forced to stand and be forced after future legislation. Dumb sings the national anthem.
Zhang Chaoxiong, a member of the Legislative Council, pointed out that the draft states that attending people who play the national anthem need to stand up and behave solemnly. Although the Government has publicly explained that it is not illegal to insult the national anthem, the propaganda film may mislead the public and it is also necessary to stand up. Request the government to clarify.
Nie Dequan explained that the propaganda film was not produced by the government. He also pointed out that if the mother-in-law in the clip wanted to get up and expressed respect for the national anthem, she played again and the incident was completely problem-free. He also reiterated that if he could not stand because of his physical condition, it would be no problem to stand without singing the national anthem.
The Agriculture and Fisheries Federation's Agriculture and Fisheries Councillor, He Junxian, refuted the lawmakers' arguments, saying that the mother-in-law in the film was an anti-Japanese veteran of the Dongjiang column. It was very patriotic. Guo Jiaxuan said that the old man was insulting.
The DAB also added clarification. The elders in the episode are an anti-Japanese veteran. They have experienced the suffering of the country. They believe that the country should be respected. They usually use wheelchairs to walk, but they can stand up and listen to the national anthem every time. Try to stand up to show respect, the content of the clip is real, not the producer
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/政情網上行-站% E7%AB%8B%E5%94%B1%E5%9C%8B%E6%AD%8C-110000263.html
[political online] standing singing national anthem
[now.com News]
Now.com news
2.6k person tracking
May 2, 2019, 7:00 PM
[political online] standing singing national anthem
[forced standing?]
Youth group launches national anthem flash event
In addition to the political and business people and artists responded
There is a middle in the fragment
Sitting in a wheelchair
Stand up when you hear the national anthem
National Ant Code Act Committee
Citizen Party Guo Jiaxuan asked Nie Dequan
The law will abuse abusers
#国歌法#Legislative Council #聂德权#郭家麒
#香港新闻#Political News
#政情在线行
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/輪椅婆婆聽國歌肅立民主派質疑虐老-建制派反駁為愛國抗日老戰士-132300205.html
輪椅婆婆聽國歌肅立民主派質疑虐老 建制派反駁為愛國抗日老戰士
星島日報
18.2k 人追蹤
2019年5月2日 下午9:23
宣傳片中坐輪椅的婆婆,聽國歌時肅立。國歌快閃片段截圖
【星島日報報道】「香港各界青少年活動委員會」近日推出3分鐘國歌短片,找來名人上鏡獻唱,還有個坐輪椅的老婦,撐住拐杖、由旁人攙扶下起身肅立唱歌。公民黨立法會議員郭家麒今日在法案委員會上批評,勉強老人家聽到國歌起身顯示愛國精神是「低級趣味」,要求政制及內地事務局長聶德權譴責做法是傷害老人家,擔心日後立法後強迫長者站立、強迫啞巴唱國歌。
立法會議員張超雄指出,草案列明奏唱國歌時出席人士需要肅立和舉止莊重,政府雖曾公開解釋,若無侮辱國歌的意圖便不屬違法,但宣傳片或會誤導公眾行動不便亦必須肅立,要求政府澄清。
聶德權解釋,宣傳片並非政府製作。他又指,如果片段中的婆婆想起身表達對國歌的尊重,她又起到身,事件完全無問題。他又重申,若因身體狀况而無法站立,在奏唱國歌場合不站立是無問題。
民建聯的漁農界議員何俊賢就反駁議員講法,稱片中的婆婆是東江縱隊抗日老戰士,非常有愛國情懷,郭家麒稱勉強老人講法是侮辱。
民建聯陳恒鑌亦加入澄清,片段中的長者是一名抗日的老戰士,經歷過國家受苦難的日子,認為國家應該受到尊重,平時借助輪椅行路,但可以站起來,每次聽到國歌時都會盡量站起來以示尊重,片段內容真人真事,並非製作人創作出來
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/政情網上行-站立唱國歌-110000263.html
【政情網上行】站立唱國歌
now.com 新聞
2.6k 人追蹤
2019年5月2日 下午7:00
【政情網上行】站立唱國歌
【強制站立?】
青年團體發起國歌快閃活動
除咗有政商界及藝人響應
片段中仲有一位
坐輪椅嘅婆婆
聽到國歌就站起來
國歌法法案委員會上
公民黨郭家麒質問聶德權
法例會唔會虐待殘疾人士
#國歌法 #立法會 #聶德權 #郭家麒
#香港新聞 #政治新聞
#政情網上行
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/%E8%BC%AA%E6%A4%85%E5%A9%86%E5%A9%86%E8%81%BD%E5%9C%8B%E6 %AD%8C%E8%82%85%E7%AB%8B%E6%B0%91%E4%B8%BB%E6%B4%BE%E8%B3%AA%E7%96%91%E8%99 %90%E8%80%81-%E5%BB%BA%E5%88%B6%E6%B4%BE%E5%8F%8D%E9%A7%81%E7%82%BA%E6%84% 9B%E5%9C%8B%E6%8A%97%E6%97%A5%E8%80%81%E6%88%B0%E5%A3%AB-132300205.html
Wheelchair mother-in-law listens to the national anthem, and the democratic party questioned the elder abuse. The establishmentist refuted the patriotic anti-Japanese warrior.
[Sing Tao Daily]
Sing Tao Daily
18.2k person tracking
May 2, 2019, 9:23 PM
The mother-in-law who was in a wheelchair in the propaganda film stood up when listening to the national anthem. National Anthem Flash Clip Screenshot
[Sing Tao Daily News] "Hong Kong Youth Activities Committee" recently launched a three-minute national anthem short film, looking for celebrities to sing on the mirror, and an elderly woman in a wheelchair, holding a cane, and helping others to stand up and sing. The Citizens Party Legislative Council member, Mr Kwok Ka-wai, criticized the Bills Committee today. It is "low-level interest" to force the elderly to hear the national anthem and show that patriotism is a "low-level interest". The Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs, Nie De-kwong, has condemned the practice of harming the elderly and fearing that the elderly will be forced to stand and be forced after future legislation. Dumb sings the national anthem.
Zhang Chaoxiong, a member of the Legislative Council, pointed out that the draft states that attending people who play the national anthem need to stand up and behave solemnly. Although the Government has publicly explained that it is not illegal to insult the national anthem, the propaganda film may mislead the public and it is also necessary to stand up. Request the government to clarify.
Nie Dequan explained that the propaganda film was not produced by the government. He also pointed out that if the mother-in-law in the clip wanted to get up and expressed respect for the national anthem, she played again and the incident was completely problem-free. He also reiterated that if he could not stand because of his physical condition, it would be no problem to stand without singing the national anthem.
The Agriculture and Fisheries Federation's Agriculture and Fisheries Councillor, He Junxian, refuted the lawmakers' arguments, saying that the mother-in-law in the film was an anti-Japanese veteran of the Dongjiang column. It was very patriotic. Guo Jiaxuan said that the old man was insulting.
The DAB also added clarification. The elders in the episode are an anti-Japanese veteran. They have experienced the suffering of the country. They believe that the country should be respected. They usually use wheelchairs to walk, but they can stand up and listen to the national anthem every time. Try to stand up to show respect, the content of the clip is real, not the producer
https://hk.news.yahoo.com/政情網上行-站% E7%AB%8B%E5%94%B1%E5%9C%8B%E6%AD%8C-110000263.html
[political online] standing singing national anthem
[now.com News]
Now.com news
2.6k person tracking
May 2, 2019, 7:00 PM
[political online] standing singing national anthem
[forced standing?]
Youth group launches national anthem flash event
In addition to the political and business people and artists responded
There is a middle in the fragment
Sitting in a wheelchair
Stand up when you hear the national anthem
National Ant Code Act Committee
Citizen Party Guo Jiaxuan asked Nie Dequan
The law will abuse abusers
#国歌法#Legislative Council #聂德权#郭家麒
#香港新闻#Political News
#政情在线行