How come they keep changing their leader? Imagine just before the next election in Singapore LHL is replaced! Would Singaporean vote for PAP still? Or be put off?
http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/political-news/pm-heeds-call-for-leadership-spill-20130321-2ghh9.html
http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/political-news/pm-heeds-call-for-leadership-spill-20130321-2ghh9.html
PM heeds call for leadership spill
Date
March 21, 2013 - 3:15PM
1654 reading nowComments 215 VoteRead later
Dan Harrison and Daniel Hurst
inShare
Pin Itsubmit to redditEmail articlePrintReprints & permissions
Gillard announces spill
Julia Gillard announces that caucus will vote on the Labor leadership and deputy leadership at 4.30pm Thursday.
Autoplay ONOFFVideo feedbackVideo settings
Simon Crean's opening statement to the media
Prime Minister Julia Gillard has heeded ALP frontbencher Simon Crean's call for a spill of the Labor leadership.
''For the information of the House I have determined that there will be a ballot for the leadership and deputy leadership of the Labor party at 4.30pm (Melbourne/Sydney time). In the meantime, take your best shot.''
Leader of the House Anthony Albanese in discussion with Prime Minister Julia Gillard during question time on March 21. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
Ms Gillard said Anthony Albanese would answer questions in question time in Mr Crean's portfolio.
Advertisement
Earlier on Thursday Mr Crean asked the prime minister to call a spill of the Labor leadership.
Kevin Rudd-backers had already prepared a petition calling for a spill before Ms Gillard responded by calling on the fight.
Labor MP Kevin Rudd arrives at question time after ALP frontbencher Simon Crean called for a spill of the leadership.
Mr Rudd has not yet revealed whether he will nominate for the leadership but the momentum is believed to be with him.
Deputy Prime Minister Wayne was standing by Ms Gillard ahead of the ballot, tweeting: "As I said yesterday, @JuliaGillard is as tough as they make them- she'll win today & on 14 Sept because she’s got the reforms for the future."
In question time, Opposition Leader Tony Abbott asked: ''Does the Prime Minister agree with former prime minister Bob Hawke that if you can't govern yourselves, you can't govern the country?''
Independent MPs Andrew Wilkie, Craig Thomson, Rob Oakeshott and Tony Windsor talk during the motion of no confidence during question time. Photo: Andrew Meares
Ms Gillard replied: ''I certainly believe that as a government you've got to keep your focus on the things that matter to the Australian people and that's where my focus is.''
Mr Abbott then sought to move a motion that the House of Representatives had no confidence in the Prime Minister.
In seeking to suspend standing orders to move a motion of no confidence, Mr Abbott said Australia had been let down by an ''incompetent'' government that got worse by the hour.
Labor frontbencher Simon Crean announces he has asked Julia Gillard for a spill of the party leadership. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen
''Not only does the Coalition have no confidence in this Prime Minister but plainly senior members of her own government no longer have confidence in this Prime Minister,'' Mr Abbott said.
Mr Abbott described Mr Crean as a ''decent, honourable man'' who had made a ''remarkable'' statement about the state of the Labor party.
He said: ''This is a government which has lost its way; not a good government that has lost its way but a very poor government that has lost its way.''
In a stark message to Ms Gillard, Mr Abbott declared across the dispatch box: ''Can I say to our current Prime Minister. For your party's good, you should go, for our country's good you should go. You should go.''
In a reference to the media reforms that had been killed off, Mr Abbott congratulated the crossbench MPs ''for standing up for the sacred principles of free speech on which our democracy depends''.
''There has been policy failure after policy failure,'' he said.
Mr Abbott said it was time to give the Australian people a chance to choose the government.
''The Labor Party of which it was once said there was a light on the hill, working for the betterment of mankind, not just here but wherever we can lend a helping hand, that once great political party is now reduced to being a life support system, a political life support system for just one person, the current Prime Minister,'' he said.
Ms Gillard hit back at the opposition describing Mr Abbott's and Deputy Opposition Leader Julie Bishop's speeches as reflecting ''the same negative dummy spit that they've been engaged in since the 2010 election''.
Ms Gillard said Mr Abbott had the opportunity to outline a vision to the Australian people but he had failed and instead responded ''with the only thing he knows how to do - that is negativity, bitterness and the politics of personal assault''.
''Their lack of vision, the inability in opposition to come up with any costed, credible policies for the nation condemns them to where they should be and that is the opposition benches,'' she said.
Ms Gillard stressed the strength of the Australian economy and outlined her achievements, including in the education field.
''Let me assure the Leader of the Opposition we are not done yet; we have more to do to bring fairness and opportunity in our country.''
Ms Gillard said her party had always worked to ensure economic benefits were spread across the nation.
''It's what it's done under my prime ministership and it is what it will do under my prime ministership from this day forward,'' she said.
''We will fight and fight and fight the Leader of the Opposition's campaign to take opportunity away from families, to visit cutbacks on their heads . . .
''We will fight and fight and fight that and when the election is held in September we will prevail in that election because the choice will be so clear."
Mr Abbott's bid to suspend standing orders failed. The motion passed 73 votes to 71, but it would have required an absolute majority (76) to succeed.
'Something needs to be done'
During Mr Crean's press conference earlier in the day he said: "Something needs to be done to break this deadlock . . . for once and for all.''
''I am asking her to call a spill of all leadership positions,'' Mr Crean told journalists in Canberra. ''I will not be standing for the leader. I will be putting myself forward in the leadership team for the deputy leader.''
Mr Crean, who is the Arts and Regional Australia Minister, said Mr Rudd had no alternative but to stand for the leadership. He said he would be supporting Mr Rudd.
To win a ballot, Mr Rudd needs a majority of votes in the 102-member caucus. Last February, he could only muster just 31 votes to Julia Gillard's 71.
He said if Ms Gillard was elected in a leadership ballot he would not contest the ballot for deputy and would resign from the cabinet.
Asked if Mr Rudd had enough support to become leader, Mr Crean said: ''I wouldn't be doing this if I did not believe there was the mood and the need for change within the party.''
Mr Crean said he had not spoken to Mr Rudd in the past 48 hours. He said he had spoken to Mr Rudd over a long period of time and believed Mr Rudd could be a ''changed Kevin'', ''a more disciplined
asset''.
Mr Crean reaffirmed that he had concerns about the way in which the former Rudd government was run, but he believed Mr Rudd could change.
''That's a discussion I've continued to have with him. I'm satisfied that this can change but I want to be there to ensure it is changed,'' he said.
Asked whether the September 14 election date was shaky, Mr Crean said he believed the government should run full term.
''I do not believe the position we find ourselves in the polls for example is just due to destabilisation [by the Rudd forces],'' he said.
''I think it is true a number of decision which obviously in hindsight should have been approached differently.
''There is no ticket between me and Kevin. I think he has another view as to who his deputy should be. I
disagree with that view,'' Mr Crean said.
He said if the caucus wanted to see a ''change of leadership, not just a change of leader'' they should support him for deputy.
''It seems to me the party . . . is in a stalemate position,'' he said. ''Something must be done to resolve this issue once and for all.''
''We can't win from the position we're in in the polls,'' he said. But he said Labor's woes were not only about leadership.
''People have got to believe that we have conviction. What we have to do is to take people with us. That means being prepared to argue the case.''
He said the caucus needed to act ''expeditiously, decisively and conclusively''.
''I am urging Mr Rudd to put his name forward in the interests of breaking the deadlock.''
''We've got to reclaim the success of the Labor mantle. What I am challenging the party to do is to look beyond the prism of the two individuals.
''Some will say this is just rewarding the destabilisers . . . but I do not believe that the position we find ourselves in in the polls is just due to destabilisation.''
He said the party's poor standing was partly due to ''a number of decisions'', which he said had been approached poorly. He would not detail these.
He said his decision had been ''very difficult''. He said colleagues had urged him to nominate for leader but he had resisted these calls.
Mr Crean finished his media conference by declaring: ''I'm going to be in question time at two o'clock as I'm required to be.''
Labor Senator Ursula Stephens has tweeted that she hopes Mr Rudd will nominate for the leadership, after retweeting a tweet from a fake Rudd account suggesting the former prime minister would challenge.
''Sorry folks that was a phony Kevin Rudd tweet, but I sure hope the real one will step up!'' Senator Stephens tweeted.
Victorian Labor MP Richard Marles said that he believed Mr Rudd could lead the party to an election victory.
''Frankly it needed to be brought to a head,'' he told Sky News.
''I think our best chance of winning at the next election is with Kevin Rudd. I think that is the fact of the matter.''
Follow the National Times on Twitter
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/polit...rship-spill-20130321-2ghh9.html#ixzz2O936o9Xw
