• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

Ah Neh Vs Goliaths

saratogas

Alfrescian
Loyal
Joined
Jul 15, 2008
Messages
3,563
Points
38
2005062700290401.jpg

This Ah neh got Balls!

Owner of private schools suing NTUC Income, CASE breaks down in court

Drama broke out on Monday during the High Court case dubbed as "David versus two goliaths".

The single owner of two private schools is fighting it out with the Consumers Association of Singapore (CASE) and insurance company NTUC Income. The schools allegedly failed to insure more than 400 students.

Channel NewsAsia is not able to show what happened inside the court room but school owner Mr Kannappan Chettiar broke down after questioning by Senior Counsel Cavinder Bull.

Mr Bull had quizzed his intentions for taking legal action. He asked if Mr Kannappan was being "frivolous" in trying to force CASE to apologise through the lawsuit.

Mr Kannappan said: "Yes, I want an apology," — before wiping off his tears.

Mr Kannappan is suing both CASE and NTUC Income for some S$10 million, claiming his schools were wrongfully suspended from an important accreditation scheme.
 
2005062700290401.jpg


"Don't worry, everything is going bullish & my way."


.
 
20071125.101301_top_news_stansfield_st.jpg

JUST two days after lodging complaints against the Consumers Association of Singapore (Case) for anti-competitive practices, The Stansfield Group has filed a lawsuit against the consumer watchdog.
In the suit filed on Friday evening, lawyers representing the company behind private schools here allege that Case had breached an agreement governing insurance payments that effectively hampered its ability to bring in foreign students.
This tarnished the schools' reputation, which resulted in existing students pulling out, and a drop in enrolment as well for new ones, it alleges.

Stansfield Group chairman Kannappan Chettiar said that the school is still assessing the damage but 'estimates it to be around $20 million'.
It all started last November when Case suspended the CaseTrust membership of Stansfield's two schools - Stansfield College and the Singapore Institute of Commerce - for 23 days.
Private schools which want to enrol international students are required to join a scheme called CaseTrust for Education, which is managed by Case.
This means schools must deposit students' fee payments into a separate bank account, which releases the money to the schools in instalments. Alternatively, schools can buy insurance policies so students are refunded the remainder of their fees should the school close down.
Stansfield maintains that Case has endorsed NTUC Income as the sole provider of this insurance scheme, and in October last year, the insurer suspended Stansfield's student insurance policies.
Income's exclusive rights to provide insurance for private schools was the crux of Stansfield's complaint to the Competition Commission of Singapore.
Case rebutted Stansfield's complaint on Friday, objecting to allegations that it had the power to appoint Income. Rather, Case and Income were invited to participate in the scheme by the Economic Development Board. Besides, the school also had the option to use the bank deposit system.
As to the suspension of the school's CaseTrust membership, the consumer group's executive director, Mr Seah Seng Choon, told The Sunday Times this happened because it had failed to comply with rules protecting students' fee payments.
Stansfield's two schools had appeared to have breached the rules when it was discovered that some of their foreign students did not have insurance.
Stansfield, however, is suing Case on the grounds that it was not given a chance to answer Case's allegations regarding its non-compliance, as it was entitled to under the CaseTrust membership agreement code, before being suspended.
During the 23-day suspension, foreign students who had already enrolled with Stansfield were left stranded as their student passes could not be issued. Case lifted the suspension on Dec 13 when Stansfield met the scheme's requirements.
But the school's troubles mounted when, in the same month, China's Education Ministry advised students and education agents to avoid dealing with six schools here, including Stansfield's, as they had been suspended by Case. The advisory was lifted this April.
This, the school says, has resulted in students withdrawing and a drop in fresh enrolment numbers.
Last year, Stansfield's two schools had about 2,700 students, with around 1,100 foreigners. Now, there are just 300 foreigners out of a total student body of 1,800. 'We used to get about 70 to 100 new students per month; now we can't even get seven,' said Mr Chettiar.
The school had also closed its China offices in Shanghai and Beijing this February.
Media reports, Stansfield claims, have also left their students in Singapore worried.
'A batch of 40 students all went to another school after they finished their semester,' said Mr Chettiar, who founded Stansfield in 1993.
He said Stansfield College is a stable institute which has bagged the Enterprise 50 awards - a ranking of 50 of the most enterprising privately held Singapore corporations - for five consecutive years since 2002. It also reaped $4.47 million in after-tax profits in the year ending March 31.
When contacted, Mr Seah said Case will 'seek legal assistance' and 'respond accordingly' to the suit.
Asked why he decided to file the suit now, Mr Chettiar said: 'Stansfield's reputation in the eyes of the public has been damaged.
'I spent 15 years building this name up and now I have to start from zero again. I need to clear our name.'
 
20090626.112621_tablaedu.jpg

The late bloomer

By Patrick Jonas

KANNAPPAN CHETTIAR
Chairman/Chief Learning Officer,
Stansfield College

HE IS a self-confessed late bloomer who has a soft spot for people like himself.
Mr Kannappan Chettiar was not one who shone academically in secondary school and junior college. His father thought he should go to NUS but KC, as he is popularly known, was not keen to study in Singapore. He says he was fortunate that his father could afford to let him do his undergraduate studies in the United States.
In his words, his best experience as a student was when he went to Michigan State University to study law: 'I felt the complete freedom to be independent and to study. I prospered very well academically and was the top in nearly every class due to this.'
KC comes from a family of lawyers, with his brother and sister following his father's footsteps in the legal profession. He too was expected to follow them but when he could not land a job on his return to Singapore, he decided to do something for late bloomers like himself. He set up a law school that offered degree courses from the University of London.
According to him, in the early 1990s, the percentage of people getting into a degree course in local universities was a low 10 per cent. From law, he moved to business programmes, also from the University of London. Today, his group runs five institutions in Singapore and one in Chennai.
'I empathise with late bloomers. Just because you did not do well in primary school does not mean you can't get a degree.
So I started focusing on helping those kind of people to get degrees. Most of my students in the 1990s would be in the age group 30 to 40 and 80 per cent of them were part-time students,' he says.
Now 43, KC has strong views about the Singapore education system. He even moved his four children to boarding schools in Los Angeles last year because he felt they were not doing well here due to the system.
The problem in Singapore, he says, is that 'it has become an education system and not a learning system'.
'Learners get to choose. The more you teach, the less the children get to learn.
Learning assumes that most knowledge is yet to be discovered or found. I believe that the only way to discover more knowledge is to allow yourself the freedom to discover it,' he says.
KC is a Tamil and his wife a Malayali. The family speaks mostly English at home and his children found it difficult to handle Tamil in school while they were in Singapore.
Things have improved since the children moved to the US and he feels that in just one year his children - daughters Prasheena, 17, and Shabreena, 16 and sons Krishant, 14, and Veshant, 11 - have become much more independent in what they want to do.
With the children away in the US, KC and his wife Cenobia spend most of their time in Chennai focusing on the campus there. She helps him in managing the campus.
India, as KC discovered, is not an easy place to do business but he is determined to make it a success. He started out in India in 2003, signing a deal with a Mumbai group but it did not work out. The Indian partner, he says, did not stick to the agreement and so he dropped the plan. He then moved to Chennai thinking that 'at least I could speak Tamil'.
He set up a state-of-the-art campus on Anna Salai near Spencer Plaza. But it has not been smooth sailing for him and that explains his spending considerable time in Chennai.
When I met him at the Stansfield College in Singapore, he told me that even though he comes down to Singapore often, he has been here for less than 20 days this year. 'In Singapore I have got good people in place so it is easier for us to run the institutions. But in India if I don't do it myself, things never get done,' he says.
When he set out in Chennai, the school attracted a lot of media attention with the then Education Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam inaugurating it. But with it, those envious of the school also set to work. It took him two years to sort out the legal wrangles that followed.
'In India, I am just learning,' he admits.
Though he speaks Tamil, he says 'culturally, I am very different. My expectations are different'. The pace, too, is different and he finds it frustrating: 'To operate in India, you need to be very cool and cannot have very high expectations. But my vision in India is big. I don't want to be a failure.'
Part of his vision is a school on American lines with small classrooms. Why India and not Singapore? 'India is more welcoming to change, plus it has a large population,' he replies.
KC is so passionate about learning that it dominated our conversation. And when I asked him about his home, he startled me by first saying he lived in the Stansfield hostel. A man with four children having a hostel as his home, I thought, was strange. He then gave his reasons.
The hostel is beside the former crematorium at Mount Vernon and when it was set up, not all were happy with the location.
So to prove that it is a safe place to live, KC gave up his Serangoon Gardens home and moved into a 6,000 sq ft apartment within the hostel.
He also has a home in Mylapore, not very far from his Chennai campus. When his children arrive for their summer holidays, they will spend some time in Chennai too, even though they claim there is very little for them to do there. But for KC, it is another learning experience for the children.
Not surprising since it comes from a man whose name card reads Chairman/Chief Learning Officer.
 
2005080700240401.jpg

Kannappan Chettiar, who heads Stansfield Group, interacting with students at the Stansfield Business School in the state-of-the-art complex (right) on Anna Salai in Chennai. The Group plans to invest about Rs. 500 crores in setting up 20 international business schools in India.


ssb_chennai.jpg

Officially Opened on Tuesday, 13th September 2005
by Mr Tharman Shanmugaratnam, Minister for Education, Singapore
 
Jan 19, 2010
Private schools' suit halted
By Selina Lum

THE lawsuit taken out by two private schools against the Consumers Association of Singapore (Case) and NTUC Income came to a temporary halt on Tuesday after the lawyer for the schools discharged himself.
The lawyer, Mr Devinder K. Rai, was later given permission by the High Court to do so.
The hearing, which is scheduled to run till Jan 29, has now been stopped to give time for the schools' new lawyer - Mr Gregory Vijayendran - to take over.
The schools - Stansfield College and the Singapore Institute of Commerce (SIC), both owned by Mr Kannappan Chettiar - are asking for about $10 million in losses, which they claim was the result of their 23-day suspension from a Case-accredited scheme in 2006.
The High Court hearing, which ran for nine days in November and December last year, resumed last Friday.
Case is represented by Senior Counsel Cavinder Bull, while Income's lawyer is Senior Counsel Lok Vi Ming.

gregory.jpg

Gregory Vijayendran take over the case
 
Back
Top