https://www.algemeiner.com/2024/04/...t-iran-onslaught-leads-calls-increase-budget/
Israel must increase its defense budget significantly after seeing the high cost of defending the Jewish state against Iran’s massive drone and missile salvo on Saturday night, according to a former adviser to Israel’s top military official.
The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has “no chance of reaching a situation where you are able to maintain the required defense” unless the country’s current military budget is “doubled,” Brig. Gen. (Res.) Ram Aminach, the former economic adviser to the military’s chief of staff, told Israeli television on Sunday.
Israel, with the help of allies including the US, repelled the Iranian attack with striking success. According to IDF Chief Spokesperson Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, “99 percent of the threats launched towards Israeli territory were intercepted — a very significant strategic achievement. Of approximately 170 unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) that Iran launched, zero crossed into Israeli territory. From the more than 30 cruise missiles Iran launched, none crossed into Israeli territory.”
Additionally, “out of over 120 ballistic missiles, only a few crossed into Israeli territory, with the rest being intercepted.”
However, defending against Iran’s more than 300 drones and missiles cost Israel between 4 and 5 billion NIS ($1-$1.3 billion), according to the IDF. These figures included the high cost of operating the army’s coveted air defense systems such as the Arrow and David’s Sling, both of which were used on Saturday and can cost more than a few million dollars per firing.
Aminach argued that it’s much cheaper for Iran to continue launching such attacks than it is for Israel to defend them, presenting a potential problem of attrition for the Jewish state unless Jerusalem increases its defense budget.
“For the Iranians, it costs less than 10 percent of what it costs us to stop it,” he explained. “If we look into the future, in a year, two years, or five years, they can also conduct 50 such attacks, and you want to be ready for the number of attacks. So, we need to try to understand how much defense we need. Let’s say if the IDF’s net budget in 2023 was 60 billion shekels, with less than double that you have no chance of reaching the required quantities.”
When asked where the additional money would come from, Aminach claimed that bringing Israel’s ultra-Orthodox Jewish population more into the workforce would “contribute to the GDP approximately 150 billion.”
Aminach’s comments came as Iran threatened to up the scale of its attack if Israel chose to retaliate. “If the Zionist regime or its supporters demonstrate reckless behavior, they will receive a decisive and much stronger response,” Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi said of a potential Israeli response.
World leaders, especially in the US and Europe, have been urging Israel to show restraint in its response and to de-escalate tensions.
Saturday’s unprecedented attack was the first time that Iran targeted Israel directly from Iranian soil rather than through its proxies, a move that drew global condemnation. A coalition of the US, Britain, France, Jordan, and even Saudi Arabia reportedly helped with either Israel’s defense or providing intelligence about Iran’s attack. The onslaught sounded sirens throughout Israel, with loud booms being felt far from their impact.
Leading up to the attack, Iranian officials had promised revenge for an airstrike on Iran’s consulate in Damascus, Syria last week that Iranian officials have attributed to Israel. The strike killed seven members of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC), a US-designated terrorist organization, including two senior commanders. One of the commanders allegedly helped plan the Hamas terrorist group’s Oct. 7 massacre across southern Israel.
Israel must increase its defense budget significantly after seeing the high cost of defending the Jewish state against Iran’s massive drone and missile salvo on Saturday night, according to a former adviser to Israel’s top military official.
The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has “no chance of reaching a situation where you are able to maintain the required defense” unless the country’s current military budget is “doubled,” Brig. Gen. (Res.) Ram Aminach, the former economic adviser to the military’s chief of staff, told Israeli television on Sunday.
Israel, with the help of allies including the US, repelled the Iranian attack with striking success. According to IDF Chief Spokesperson Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, “99 percent of the threats launched towards Israeli territory were intercepted — a very significant strategic achievement. Of approximately 170 unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) that Iran launched, zero crossed into Israeli territory. From the more than 30 cruise missiles Iran launched, none crossed into Israeli territory.”
Additionally, “out of over 120 ballistic missiles, only a few crossed into Israeli territory, with the rest being intercepted.”
However, defending against Iran’s more than 300 drones and missiles cost Israel between 4 and 5 billion NIS ($1-$1.3 billion), according to the IDF. These figures included the high cost of operating the army’s coveted air defense systems such as the Arrow and David’s Sling, both of which were used on Saturday and can cost more than a few million dollars per firing.
Aminach argued that it’s much cheaper for Iran to continue launching such attacks than it is for Israel to defend them, presenting a potential problem of attrition for the Jewish state unless Jerusalem increases its defense budget.
“For the Iranians, it costs less than 10 percent of what it costs us to stop it,” he explained. “If we look into the future, in a year, two years, or five years, they can also conduct 50 such attacks, and you want to be ready for the number of attacks. So, we need to try to understand how much defense we need. Let’s say if the IDF’s net budget in 2023 was 60 billion shekels, with less than double that you have no chance of reaching the required quantities.”
When asked where the additional money would come from, Aminach claimed that bringing Israel’s ultra-Orthodox Jewish population more into the workforce would “contribute to the GDP approximately 150 billion.”
Aminach’s comments came as Iran threatened to up the scale of its attack if Israel chose to retaliate. “If the Zionist regime or its supporters demonstrate reckless behavior, they will receive a decisive and much stronger response,” Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi said of a potential Israeli response.
World leaders, especially in the US and Europe, have been urging Israel to show restraint in its response and to de-escalate tensions.
Saturday’s unprecedented attack was the first time that Iran targeted Israel directly from Iranian soil rather than through its proxies, a move that drew global condemnation. A coalition of the US, Britain, France, Jordan, and even Saudi Arabia reportedly helped with either Israel’s defense or providing intelligence about Iran’s attack. The onslaught sounded sirens throughout Israel, with loud booms being felt far from their impact.
Leading up to the attack, Iranian officials had promised revenge for an airstrike on Iran’s consulate in Damascus, Syria last week that Iranian officials have attributed to Israel. The strike killed seven members of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC), a US-designated terrorist organization, including two senior commanders. One of the commanders allegedly helped plan the Hamas terrorist group’s Oct. 7 massacre across southern Israel.
