• IP addresses are NOT logged in this forum so there's no point asking. Please note that this forum is full of homophobes, racists, lunatics, schizophrenics & absolute nut jobs with a smattering of geniuses, Chinese chauvinists, Moderate Muslims and last but not least a couple of "know-it-alls" constantly sprouting their dubious wisdom. If you believe that content generated by unsavory characters might cause you offense PLEASE LEAVE NOW! Sammyboy Admin and Staff are not responsible for your hurt feelings should you choose to read any of the content here.

    The OTHER forum is HERE so please stop asking.

GRC System - Scrap It ...

ILovePAP

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
Discussions over the GRC system have flared up and died down over the years – especially every time we have an election – and there has been no shortage of criticism. It is time for us to really think about changing this Weird System.

My suggestion :

1. All constituencies to be Single Seat.

2. GRC Scrapped.

3. Scrap Current NCMP and NMP System too.

4. Say if Parliament is 87 seats (100%), Let's have 60% Chinese 30 Malays 15% Indians 5% Others. So if Total elected is short of this quota, Selected Representatives from these Race Groups will be nominated to be NMPs to make up for the % as pre-decided and more importantly, a fairer way for their voice to be heard.

Ideas Please...
 

ILovePAP

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
This method will endure we do not abuse the GRC process for "free ticket" candidates into Parliament.

Whether PAP or Oppo, the system has to be fair and just.
 

sochi2014

Alfrescian
Loyal
5% of electoral votes should get the party to send in one representative as MP in Parliament.

Blady hell some oppositions party get 10-15% electoral votes dun get any seats in Parliament. Like that also can? Where got fair?
 
Last edited:

virus

Alfrescian
Loyal
scrap all the GRC and create one SRC.. super size RC.

God_of_Gamblers.jpg


showhand!
 

ILovePAP

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
5% of electoral votes should get the party to send in one representative as MP in Parliament.

Blady hell some oppositions party get 10-15% electoral votes dun get any seats in Parliament. Like that also can? Where got fair?
"
You cannot have that as it also allows "free ticket" candidates to get into Parliament.
 

chonburifc

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
No need 80 something MPs. 700 square kilometer island, 40 can liaoz. If MP don't hold so many directorship outside, sure have time for residents.
 

tanwahtiu

Alfrescian
Loyal
it is not a weird system. Coward Lee Con U used GRC to save himself from losing TP smc or even if he gets 51% votes it malu him.

It also used to bring his son using back door entry into parliament. In short he cheats and no respect for this old fart. Then for 20 years he hide himself behind young faces and think no one knows how devious he was. This is why you cannot trust a criminal lawyer or any lawyers.


Discussions over the GRC system have flared up and died down over the years – especially every time we have an election – and there has been no shortage of criticism. It is time for us to really think about changing this Weird System.

My suggestion :

1. All constituencies to be Single Seat.

2. GRC Scrapped.

3. Scrap Current NCMP and NMP System too.

4. Say if Parliament is 87 seats (100%), Let's have 60% Chinese 30 Malays 15% Indians 5% Others. So if Total elected is short of this quota, Selected Representatives from these Race Groups will be nominated to be NMPs to make up for the % as pre-decided and more importantly, a fairer way for their voice to be heard.

Ideas Please...
 

ILovePAP

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
No need 80 something MPs. 700 square kilometer island, 40 can liaoz. If MP don't hold so many directorship outside, sure have time for residents.

Good suggestion...we can save some tax payers money on having so many silent seaters in Parliament.
 

Satyr

Alfrescian
Loyal
Discussions over the GRC system have flared up and died down over the years – especially every time we have an election – and there has been no shortage of criticism. It is time for us to really think about changing this Weird System.

My suggestion :

1. All constituencies to be Single Seat.

2. GRC Scrapped.

3. Scrap Current NCMP and NMP System too.

4. Say if Parliament is 87 seats (100%), Let's have 60% Chinese 30 Malays 15% Indians 5% Others. So if Total elected is short of this quota, Selected Representatives from these Race Groups will be nominated to be NMPs to make up for the % as pre-decided and more importantly, a fairer way for their voice to be heard.

Ideas Please...

Oh I am sure the Pap is wondering how to fragment Aljunied back to SMCs.
 

greenies

Alfrescian
Loyal
Fat hope lah!
GRC system is created purposely for the Pappies' advantages.
One big shot can bring 3-5 members under his coattail to represent in parliament.
If everywhere SMC, sure half of the present Pappies' MPs such as TPL will never be elected.
 

ILovePAP

Alfrescian (Inf)
Asset
Fat hope lah!
GRC system is created purposely for the Pappies' advantages.
One big shot can bring 3-5 members under his coattail to represent in parliament.
If everywhere SMC, sure half of the present Pappies' MPs such as TPL will never be elected.

That is why it should be scrapped.
 

iluvgst

Alfrescian
Loyal
GRC system is only good for pap if pap has an overwhelming majority. But with the tide is turning against them, one fallen GRC will take one or more ministers down with it. GRC system will soon be their Achilles heel.
 

greenies

Alfrescian
Loyal
GRC system is only good for pap if pap has an overwhelming majority. But with the tide is turning against them, one fallen GRC will take one or more ministers down with it. GRC system will soon be their Achilles heel.

Yes, we need to show them that their safety net GRCs are no longer in their safe hands.
Now in our own hands to show them.
 
Last edited:

zhihau

Super Moderator
SuperMod
Asset
My suggestion :
1. All constituencies to be Single Seat.
2. GRC Scrapped.
3. Scrap Current NCMP and NMP System too.

i second these three suggestions without hesitation :smile::smile::smile:
all MPs should go on a 1-1 challenge in an SMC, where there's more than two candidates, candidate with highest vote count wins. NCMP and NMP aren't given voting rights when bills are passed, not elected by the electorate in any way. no need for these positions. i also second these suggestions because with the abolition of GRC, you can see PAP MPs dropping off like flies in no time :biggrin::biggrin::biggrin:
 
Top